Paying TV productions to shoot in your state may be money poorly spent

Ready, set, action!Ever wonder why so many television series are filmed in New York or Vancouver, Canada? Well, you'd shoot there too, if they offered you the cornucopia of cash savings that these areas do. Why? Because most states and some countries embrace the common wisdom that television productions bring big bucks to the local economy. This is also why the host locations for two major television series (Law and Order in New York City, Lost in Hawaii) are singing the blues as these two series come to an end.

Hard numbers about the economic loss are difficult to come by (more about that later), but, according to Bizjournals, Hawaii estimates that Lost pumped $400 million into the state's coffers during its six-season run. It reportedly employed more than 2,000 people in the last shooting year, and bought airliners-full of food, paint, wood, and other set supplies as well as renting fleets of vehicles and paying for lodging.

The original Law & Order brought New York City approximately $1 billion during its 20-year run, according to the Mayor's Office of Film, Theater and Broadcasting as reported by New York Magazine.

Given these juicy figures, it's no wonder that 41 states, numerous local communities and other countries now offer financial incentives for American TV and movie productions. In a game of one-upmanship, these entities vie by offering rebates on local labor, sales tax, production venues and services, as well as cooperation in getting access to venues.

Obviously, the wisdom of extending such largess to the industry depends on measuring the return. Do these towns, states and countries eventually recoup the lost tax revenue from the local companies that benefited from the increase in business? If not, does the production provide jobs, or does the money it spends recirculate enough to offset the investment?

Not according to a recent paper by professor Susan Christopherson of Cornell University and Ned Rightor of MXCIX. They point out that good measurements of this economic impact are almost impossible to find. Those people in the business of promoting film bureaus find them using ephemeral mulitpliers to "prove" that the tax breaks were justified, while other branches of a state government, such as the tax collectors who run their own numbers, find just the opposite.

The pair cites a Connecticut government study that found that 8% of the money invested came back to the state as tax revenue. Another study in Louisiana found revenue returns were only 16-18% of the money paid out. The Wisconsin Department of Commerce published a study using the Johnny Depp movie Public Enemies, filmed in the state. It concluded that it cost the state $925,467 of incentive money for each job created. Shortly thereafter, the state ended the program.

Christopherson and Rightor also point out that many of the jobs created are transitory, gone as soon as the production ends, and that to secure repeated business, states and communities would need specialized support such as sound stages and video-savvy labor. How can the latter be maintained if the business is episodic? With state support?

There is a certain pride a community can derive from seeing itself featured in a movie or television program. As a job creation and economic development initiative, however, proponents my have gotten Lost in the numbers, and passed laws that are bringing disorder to local budgets.

Capital Gains and Losses

What is a capital asset, and how much tax do you have to pay when you sell one at a profit? Find out how to report your capital gains and losses on your tax return with these tips from TurboTax.

Read More

Brought to you by TurboTax.com

Stimulus 2020: Unemployment Insurance for Self-Employed Individuals

Due to the recent coronavirus pandemic, many businesses and individuals are facing challenging times — including those that are self-employed. The government has issued unemployment insurance for self-employed individuals to help them manage their finances.

Read More

Brought to you by TurboTax.com

Great Ways to Get Charitable Tax Deductions

Generally, when you give money to a charity, you can use the amount of that donation as an itemized deduction on your tax return. However, not all charities qualify as tax-deductible organizations. While there are many types of charities, they must all meet certain criteria to be classified by the IRS as tax-deductible organizations. There are legitimate tax-deductible organizations in many popular categories, such as those listed below.

Read More

Brought to you by TurboTax.com

Managing Your Retirement Account and Taxes During Economic Uncertainty

In times of economic uncertainty, you might start to notice some alarming changes to your retirement account. It's usually unwise to panic and withdraw early, even if the temptation is strong.

Read More

Brought to you by TurboTax.com
Read Full Story
Your resource on tax filing
Tax season is here! Check out the Tax Center on AOL Finance for all the tips and tools you need to maximize your return.