Up in smoke: New York cigarettes hit $9 a pack

A few weeks ago, I wrote a post in which I mentioned New York's plans to raise taxes on cigarettes. Well, the bill passed, and cigarettes are now $9 a pack in New York City. While this is sure to increase tax revenue in the short run, it's not hard to see how it will backfire.

The first negative side effect is the fact that it will encourage criminal behavior on the part of ordinarily law-abiding citizens. According to a report by the Independent Budget Office, earlier tax increases led to massive growth in the purchases of illegal cigarettes. In fact, in 2006, 27% of NYC smokers and 34% of upstate smokers purchased "under-taxed" cigarettes. Now that the taxes on a pack of cigarettes have more than doubled, those figures are expected to skyrocket.
One of the easiest ways to get "under-taxed" cigarettes is through Indian reservations. For example, the Poospatuck Indian Reservation, located just 60 miles outside of New York City, is a major source for tax-free smokes, and its website, "The Original Poospatuck Smoke Shop and Trading Post," is primarily a portal for ordering tobacco products (although it also offers moccasins and coffee). The Poospatucks take their tax free smokes pretty seriously, stating that "[We were] a leader in the fight to protect the sovereignty of Unkechaug Nation lands. We are proud of our contribution to the struggle and will continue to resist any attempt to charge, collect or impose any duty on our territory. This is not just about cigarettes or gas, this is the lawful exercise of Sovereignty [...] The consumer who purchases from our site not only buys at a great discount, but also makes a statement about protecting the rights and obligations of our people."

Cheap smokes and a political statement? Hell, sign me up!

For the less politically motivated addicts, there are also internet sites that will sell cigarettes at a considerable discount and ship them to New York addresses. Although these sites are of questionable legality, enforcement is very difficult.

Governor Spitzer worked with credit card companies and postal regulators to reduce the impact of online retailers, but it's not too hard to circumvent the law on this one. Similarly, it's pretty easy to buy a trunkload of cigarettes while on vacation in Virginia or South Carolina. With the rising taxes, this sort of low-level smuggling will probably skyrocket, given the fact that it is a quick and relatively safe way to make a lot of money. It's not hard to imagine cash-strapped yuppies trying out bootlegging, particularly when a couple of runs could cover a semester's college tuition, a set of braces, or half a tank of gas.

Of course, the biggest source of cheap cigarettes will be hijackers, and therein lies another major downside to the tax hike. Historically, Prohibition was the greatest gift that the United States ever gave to organized crime. Prior to that, the mafia was largely composed of low-scale thugs involved in numbers running and prostitution, but the influx of cash from smuggled liquor gave them a big boost of adrenalin and laid the groundwork for their later expansion into unions and narcotics. Even now, it's not hard to find cigarettes that "fell off the truck." In fact, "fell off the truck" is the major cigarette retailer in my neighborhood, where I'm constantly bugged by guys selling loose packs of Newports.

By the way, can anyone tell me why Newports are the official cigarettes of the inner city?

While they may bring in a little cash flow, New York's recent tax decisions are going to put a lot of wear and tear on law enforcement in the city. Furthermore, as anti-smoking lobbyists are pushing these sorts of laws across the country, it's not hard to imagine a whole new era of bootlegging and smuggling.

Welcome to 1920!

Bruce Watson is a freelance writer, blogger, and all-around cheapskate. While he doesn't really believe that the 1920's will return, he is hoping that the fedora will make a comeback.

Groceries: Where is your food budget seeing the biggest hit?
See Gallery
Up in smoke: New York cigarettes hit $9 a pack
We'll look at some of our list of 14 of the biggest grocery price increases this year, using average prices throughout the U.S., between December 2006 and December 2007. What's up the most? Click along and see.
Ground beef has stayed cheap (though some critics would say, at a terrible price, given the recent videos of tortured cows that have shocked the nation). Up only 3.7% nationwide, it's still what's for dinner.
My kids love bananas, and many have called bananas the perfect food. They'd be a little more perfect if they were less expensive; up 5.2% this year.
Strawberries are feeling the weight of the many miles they must travel during the winter; prices are up 5.9%, on average, in the U.S. this year.
Bacon may make everything taste better, but it's not going to leave a good taste in your mouth when you pay 6.7% more than you did, this time, last year.
Perhaps due to the continued upswing in local wineries, table wine hasn't gone up in price much this year compared to many other groceries. But still, at 8%, it's higher than most American's raises. Will it be the thing to leave off *your* list?
That American apple pie will be quite a bit more pricey this year, and apples for the teacher will put your kids back 9% more -- will you give them a raise in their allowance, to match?
Beef may be America's traditional meat choice, but chicken is far more ubiquitous on lunch trays everywhere I eat. The favorite white meat of my children is 10% more expensive this year, than last.
Paradoxically, bread is only up about 13%, whereas flour has increased nearly twice that much. Could it be that flour has decreased as a percentage of the makeup of bread, or is it just random market forces? Either way, consumers are encouraged to buy their bread in already-baked form this year, though it will set you back 12% more than in late 2006.
George Bush the elder may not have liked it much, but it's extremely good for your body, that broccoli. Not so good for your wallet, with prices going up 13.4% between 2006 and 2007.
You may not see coffee as a vital part of your grocery shopping experience, but *I* do, and my budget has taken quite a hit this year. Coffee prices are up 18% between December 2006 and December 2007.
If anything is the stuff of life in my house, it's flour. And this year, flour costs quite a bit more than it did last year, up 25%.
Milk is a commodity whose price changes almost as much as gas, riding up and down based on a complicated calculation made by the USDA Federal Milk Marketing Office. You learn something new every day! And today, you should also know that milk's expensive, up nearly 29% year-over-year.
Tomatoes, which in winter must be shipped long distances to the average U.S. market, were up big between December 2006 and December 2007; the average tomato this winter is about $1.00.
In the past 12 months, eggs have gone up 36% in price, on average, throughout the U.S.; a dozen eggs in a local market here in Portland is usually over $2.00 today.
Read Full Story

From Our Partners