Ask WalletPop about home equity loans: Is 15-year or 30-year better?

A friend e-mailed me with a question about a home equity loan her family is considering. They're going through a credit union, and weighing whether to get a loan at a 15-year term, with 6.75% or Prime minus 50 bps, or a 30-year term with 7.00% or Prime minus 25 bps. "But we'll probably be selling the house in five years!" she said. "What should we do?"

I explained to her that when she was selling really shouldn't weigh into this decision; the terms of the home equity loan almost certainly indicate that it will be paid off whenever the house is sold (it's a "material change" and you can't use the equity of a home you don't own anymore as collateral). Mortgages, home equity loans, and home equity lines of credit are rarely carried to the 10-, 15-, 30- or 40-year term on the contracts, as most homeowners sell their houses or refinance their debt every five years or so. As long as the payments for the 15-year term could fit in her budget, I said, she should take that option; the interest rate was lower and that's all that really matters in the medium-term outlook.

Then she explained the unusual terms of this credit union's loans; the payment was calculated, not based on the term and interest rate, but based on the size of the loan. For $100,000, the payments were $1,200 a month no matter what. I did the math; on the 6.75% loan, the payoff amount would be more than $2,000 less than the 7.00% loan. Easy decision, and it's my mantra: always pick the lowest interest rate.

There's on caveat, of course, and that's origination fees and other costs associated with signing the loan. In this scenario, the 15-year and 30-year loans had similar fees. But if you were to compare loans from different institutions, you'd want to add fees into your equation. If the 7.00% loan, for instance, had $2,500 less in origination fees (which would be unusual for a home equity loan like this), I would have advised my friend select that option.
Read Full Story

Can't get enough personal finance tips?

Sign up for Finance Report by AOL and get everything from consumer news to money tricks delivered directly to your inbox daily!

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.