Description:The American Idol voters have spoken! Erica Van Pelt was eliminated last night after singing her rendition of Billy Joel's "New York State of Mind. The only thing the 26 year older singer can say she took away from the show was her dramatic makeover.
She took Tommy Hilfiger's advice and chopped off her blonde hair and dyed it black. And even though her journey on Idol is over, at least the judges praised her makeover before she was booted off.(0:46)