Signs your local real estate market is a bubble

Before you go, we thought you'd like these...
Before you go close icon

If you were burned in 2008, the last time the housing bubble burst, you're probably (and understandably!) gun-shy about jumping into the housing market again — especially if you think your local area could be experiencing another bubble. If you buy during a bubble, overpaying for your home, you might be forced to sell for less than the property is worth — either that or stay put longer than you'd like until you build up enough equity to sell. So if you're thinking of buying, it's important to have a sense of the signs that point to a real estate bubble. Here are five of them.

1. Shaky loans are common

As we learned from the 2008 recession, subprime lending (lending to anyone with a pulse) is not sound practice. And we have made changes. "Credit remains relatively tight," says Jonathan Miller, CRE, CRP, and president of Miller Samuel Inc., a New York, NY, real estate appraisal company.

Yet the U.S. government still backs loans that some might consider risky, particularly ones that require only a 3.5% down payment, which the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) offers. Before you get too alarmed, keep in mind that the FHA has been helping people become homeowners since 1934. The underwriting standards are higher with FHA loans than with some of the subprime low-down-payment products offered in the early 2000s, explains David Reiss, professor of law at Brooklyn Law School in Brooklyn, NY.

2. There's lots of leverage

When you take out a mortgage, you're leveraging your money — the smaller the down payment you make, the more you have leveraged the deal by using the lender's money to make the purchase. "A bubble means lots of leverage," says Miller. "And this [current] cycle has been remarkably devoid of leverage." Miller cites New York City as an example. "About 45% of the transactions are cash. And for the price points below half a million dollars, the average person puts about 35% down."

RELATED: The best places in the country to buy a home instead of rent:

11 PHOTOS
10 best big cities in the US to buy a home instead of rent
See Gallery
10 best big cities in the US to buy a home instead of rent

Tampa, Florida

(Photo via Getty)

Charlotte, North Carolina

(Photo via Shutterstock)

Atlanta, Georgia

(Photo via Getty)

Miami, Florida

(Photo via Getty)

Baltimore, Maryland

(Photo via Getty)

Austin, Texas

(Photo via Getty)

St. Louis, Missouri

(Photo via Getty)

Dallas, Texas

(Photo via Getty)

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

(Photo via Shutterstock)

Detroit, Michigan

(Photo via Getty)

of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE
SHOW CAPTION +
HIDE CAPTION

3. Home prices are rising faster than salaries

When housing prices are rising and your salary isn't, you're left with two options: continue to rent, or buy a house you can barely afford. If you think your market is in a bubble, you might want to wait to buy, especially if you're really stretching to make ends meet.

"I would review the mean income levels and employment levels compared to real estate prices for signs of discord," says Michael Kelczewski, a Pennsylvania and Delaware real estate agent. "Indicators of a local real estate bubble are asset values exceeding the local market's capacity to absorb prices." Reiss says that when home prices rise faster than salaries, "It could be the sign of froth in the market."

Miller agrees that a "rapid run-up in prices that don't match wage growth leads to discussions about bubbles." But he says that as long as credit conditions from bank lenders are tight, you won't have runaway price inflation. In New York, prices aren't rising like they were, but they aren't falling either. Miller says they've leveled off and are "stuck on a high plateau."

So what do you do when affordability isn't improving in pricey markets like New York, NY, San Francisco, CA, Los Angeles, CA, or any other high-cost urban market? Buy in the burbs. Miller notes that for New York, the market is booming in the outlying suburbs.

4. Foreign demand slows

Miami, FL, might not be experiencing a bubble, but this city is in for "a serious correction," says Sep Niakan, a real estate agent in Miami. "Since we are an international city, when foreign national buyer demand slows, our markets suffer." And that's what's been happening in Miami, according to Niakan. To make matters even more difficult for Miami's housing market, throw in the Zika virus, which affected two of Miami's key tourist areas: Wynwood and Miami Beach. "They were declared Zika zones by the [U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention]," says Niakan. "That may have been the straw that broke the camel's back in a market that was already slow, as it diminished tourism and buyer demand." (The good news? Those areas are no longer Zika zones.)

5. Interest rates rise

If people are on the fence about buying a home, the fact that interest rates are really low might be enough to push them over to the house-buying side. But as soon as interest rates rise, demand for housing could fall. "If interest rates increase by 1%, all the houses suddenly become unaffordable, and you'll see a sinking housing market because they equilibrated at these historically low interest rates," says Juan Diaz, a Northern California real estate investor.

When there are no signs

Of course, you might think your market is (or isn't) in a bubble, but you could be wrong. "The problem with bubbles is that we don't know them when we see them," says Reiss. He explains that San Francisco, CA, for example, a hugely unaffordable city for most people, isn't in a bubble just because prices are high. "Bubbles do not refer to rapid price appreciation. They refer to unsustainable rapid price appreciation. [The market] is unsustainable because fundamentals do not support the appreciation."

The bottom line is, it's difficult to know whether it's really a bubble. "If homeowners buy a house that works for their family and that they can afford over the long haul, they will have made a decision that benefits them every day, even if real estate prices drop significantly," says Reiss. But heed his warning: "If homeowners instead buy a house that is a financial stretch in the belief that it will appreciate down the road and fund their retirement, there is a good chance that they have set down a road to ruin."

Do you think your local market is a bubble? Why or why not? Tell us in the comments!

The post Signs Your Local Real Estate Market Is A Bubble appeared first on Trulia's Blog.

More from Trulia.com:
How One Woman Paid Off $20K In Debt While Renting
5 Tech Checks Before Signing A Lease
4 Tips for Cutting Back Energy Bills This Winter

Read Full Story

Find a New Home

Buy
Rent
Value
Powered by Zillow

From Our Partners