36 unanswered questions we still have after watching 'Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life'

Before you go, we thought you'd like these...
Before you go close icon

WARNING: By now you should have already binged all four new episodes of Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life. If you haven't, then you clearly did not spend your Thanksgiving break well and you should leave immediately because there are MAJOR spoilers ahead...

Well, it's officially over.

After months of casting announcements, small plot teases, and an endless buzz of anticipation, Netflix's four-part revival series, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, finally premiered. Each 90-minute episode was packed with new information and shocking revelations (especially with those life-changing final four words!), but now we're left with a massive problem: We have even more questions about our Stars Hollow favorites than ever before!

20 stars who were on "Gilmore Girls" before they were famous:

21 PHOTOS
20 stars who were on 'Gilmore Girls' before they got big
See Gallery
20 stars who were on 'Gilmore Girls' before they got big

Krysten Ritter: Season 7

Before she was “Jessica Jones” and the “B---- in Apartment 23,” Ritter was just Lucy, Rory’s (Bledel) friend from Yale. Ritter showed promise in this role — more so than in her “Veronica Mars” stint the year before — but her character was bogged down in a weird storyline about her boyfriend keeping his non-relationship with Rory a secret.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Jon Hamm: Season 3, Episode 5

Before he was Don Draper, Hamm played Peyton Sanders, a man Lorelai (Graham) meets at an auction (she eventually gets his number). Unfortunately, his charms didn’t work as well on “Gilmore Girls” as they did on “Mad Men.”

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Danny Pudi: Season 6, Episodes 13 and 14; Season 7, Episodes 6 and 7

The “Community” star is fairly well-known now, but back in 2006, he was Raj, a contributor for The Yale Daily News who gifted Rory a giant blue pencil on her last day as editor.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Nick Offerman: Season 4, Episode 7; Season 6, Episode 4

The mustache is still amazing, but Beau Belleville couldn’t be more different than Offerman’s star-making turn as Ron Swanson. Beau was Jackson’s (Jackson Douglas) brother who thought Lorelai was a nymphomaniac and made some weird facial expressions because of it.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Leslie Odom Jr.: Season 6, Episode 16

The “Hamilton” star just won a Tony Award, but 10 years ago, he appeared in one episode as a pompous guy from Princeton who joined Rory on a panel about journalism.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Seth MacFarlane: Season 2, Episodes 20 and 21

MacFarlane had already been the voice of Stewie Griffin for about three years when he had a small stint on “Gilmore Girls.” Fox notoriously canceled “Family Guy” in 2002 before reviving it in 2005, so in the meantime, MacFarlane kept himself busy. He played Zack, a peer in Lorelai’s graduating class who hates the rich and is mean to Lorelai.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Victoria Justice: Season 4, Episode 3

Justice became the queen of Nickelodeon, but her very first role is credited as “Jill #2” in this 2003 episode of the show. Justice sports some elf ears as an attendee of a “Lord of the Rings”-themed party and says Sookie’s (McCarthy) food “tastes like diapers,” proving the lovable chef doesn’t understand what children want. (What is gravlax anyway?)

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Chad Michael Murray: Season 1

The hunk of the early 2000s was a familiar face on the first season of the show, playing Tristan Dugray, the rich boy who teased Rory, angered Dean (Padalecki), and made all the girls swoon. But Tristan is conveniently sent away to boarding school as Murray gets a stint on “Dawson’s Creek” and then of course as Lucas Scott in “One Tree Hill.”

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Mary Lynn Rajskub: Season 2, Episode 19; Season 6, Episode 22

Rajskub had two different roles on “Gilmore Girls” before she became Jack Bauer’s trusted analyst on “24.” In her first, she starred with Kirk (James Gunn) in his own film as the “favorite daughter.” In her second, she competed with and annoyed Taylor to be the town troubadour.

Watch her in "A Film by Kirk."

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Jane Lynch: Season 1, Episode 9

Lynch had an eclectic list of roles to her name before she hit it big on “Glee.” On “Gilmore Girls,” she played a nurse who had to suffer the bite of Emily Gilmore after Richard was rushed to the hospital.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Rami Malek: Season 4, Episode 11

Malek just received his first Emmy nomination for his breakout role as Elliot in “Mr. Robot.” But back in his very first acting gig, Malek was Andy, Lane’s (Keiko Agena) classmate who worked with her on a group project about interviewing a “distinguished leader.” Andy, in his sweater vest nonetheless, was passionate about picking assistant pastor Eric.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Nasim Pedrad: Season 6, Episode 16

 Pedrad does a mean impression of Kim Kardashian and was a standout on “Scream Queens,” but one of her first roles on “Gilmore Girls” didn’t give her much to do. She was simply a waitress who had to wait on a drunk and mean Rory who just found out about Logan’s exploits while they were broken up.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Vanessa Marano: Seasons 6 and 7

Marano is currently starring in Freeform’s hit “Switched at Birth,” but one of her first major roles was as Luke’s (Scott Patterson) daughter. The character was a mini-version of Rory and is somewhat the reason Luke and Lorelai broke up, so she’s quite controversial.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Max Greenfield: Season 4, Episode 4

Before he became everyone’s favorite on “New Girl,” Greenfield played Lucas, one of Dean’s friends on his bachelor-party galavant around Stars Hollow. He quips at Luke that “my name’s Luke too!” and looks concerned when Dean starts drunkenly pining for Rory on the eve of his wedding to Lindsay.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Brandon Routh: Season 1, Episode 13

Lorelai easily took down Superman in his one-episode stint on the show. Madeline and Louise ditched the Bangles concert to party with the older Jess (Routh), only to have Lorelai masterfully retrieve them and shut down Jess’ cool-guy attitude

Photo Credit: 'The CW'
Masi Oka: Season 2, Episode 4

Before he could manipulate time as Hiro Nakamura in “Heroes,” Oka could be seen for a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment in “Gilmore Girls” when Rory sneaks into a philosophy class at Harvard and quickly dominates the room.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'
Billy Burke: Season 3, Episodes 11, 12 and 14

Five years before he was Bella Swan's dad in "Twilight," Burke was Alex Lesman, the nice guy Lorelai dated for an unknown amount of time. The two met after attending a class about how to run an inn. After they double-date with Sookie and Jackson, Alex isn’t seen again though he’s mentioned and still seemed to be dating Lorelai. Maybe we’ll never know what really broke them up.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Adam Brody: Season 3

We’ll never forget Dave Rygalski. The sweet and smart guitarist won over Mrs. Kim so that he could date Lane. Brody was a great supporting player, but unfortunately Dave conveniently moved to California for college as Brody was cast to star in “The O.C.” as Seth Cohen.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Todd Lowe: Seasons 3 - 7

Gil eventually replaced Dave in the band, and Lowe’s Zack also eventually replaced him as Lane’s boyfriend and later husband. Zack was a lovable goofball, very different from Lowe’s later starring role as Terry Bellefleur on “True Blood.”

Photo Credit: 'The CW'

Melora Hardin: Season 6, Episode 22

You’ll recognize Hardin in major roles as Trudy Monk in “Monk,” Jan Levinson in “The Office,” and Tammy Cashman in “Transparent,” but first she was Carolyn “Lynnie” Bates, a psychologist the Gilmores were obviously trying to pair with Christopher. Fortunately, their attempts are muddled in Lorelai’s quintessentially fast-paced and incessant questioning.

Photo Credit: 'The CW'
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE
SHOW CAPTION +
HIDE CAPTION

Behold! 36 unanswered questions we now have after watching Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life...

MORE: 'Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life': Each Season's Biggest Moments and Those Last 4 Words Finally Revealed!

1. Did Rory ever end up tracking down her box of M.I.A. underwear?

2. What version of Rory doesn't label her moving boxes? Honestly, that was unbearably out of character.

3. Why didn't they use Gilmore Girls' theme song, "Where You Lead," by Carole King in an actual scene or in an opening credits sequence?

4. Who wrote that "hateful" letter to Emily on her birthday if it wasn't Lorelai and why didn't we ever get the answer to this?

5. What language was Emily's new maid, Berta, actually speaking?

6. Was Berta just a master manipulator who preys on new widows by confusing them with gibberish, while secretly taking over their homes with her ridiculously huge family?

EXCLUSIVE: Alexis Bledel Reacts to That Shocking Rory Twist Pregnancy Twist!

7. What happened to that massive portrait of Richard that took up a whole wall? Can we have it?

8. Is Rory definitely carrying Logan's baby?

9. What are the chances Rory got knocked up after her one-night-stand with the Wookie?

10. Why did they never address that Logan already proposed to Rory once, and she said no? Was it because it happened in the lost season – aka season seven?

11. Why was Rory so incredibly comfortable with cheating on Paul while also being the other woman in Logan's relationship?

12. Did Logan ever actually marry Odette? Did Odette ever suspect/care that her fiancé was sleeping with someone else?

EXCLUSIVE: Alexis Bledel and Matt Czuchry Defend Rory and Logan's 'Surprising' Relationship Choices

13. Why was Lorelai totally fine with Rory's "slutty" behavior and cheating now, but she was outraged when it was Dean?

14. Whatever happened to Dean's first wife, Lindsay? Is she still pissed at Rory for breaking up her marriage? (She should be.)

15. Why didn't Jess have more than three scenes?

16. Why doesn't Jess realize that he's too good for Rory now?

17. Why did they waste SO much valuable screen time with all those Stars Hollow musical scenes?

18. Are Paris and Doyle really done for good? If so, WHY?

MORE: 'Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life' Totally Replaced Chad Michael Murray With Another Actor

19. Why would Tristan attend Chilton's Alumni Day when he never really actually graduated from Chilton?

20. Why did they even include that Tristian Dugray reject? Was Chad Michael Murray really THAT busy?

21. Why weren't Paris and Rory's former BFFs, Madeline and Louise, at Chilton's Alumni Day? (At least they actually graduated from the school...)

22. Why did Sookie completely abandon her dream of co-owning the Dragonfly with Lorelai? (FYI: Eating dirt and moving to the woods is not a good enough answer.)

23. With the expansion of The Dragonfly officially happening, is Michel still going to leave and work for The W in New York?

24. Did Michel ever find out why Molly Daniel was named Molly?

WATCH: Scott Patterson Talks 'Gilmore Girls' Finale and What's Next for Luke and Lorelai

25. Since when has there been a community pool in Stars Hollow?

26. Did Stars Hollow ever host their LGBT pride parade?

27. What happened to Rory's book collaborator, Naomi Shropshire? Did all those people she stole food from ever get to eat?

28. Why didn't anyone tell Rory that her "lucky outfit" looked awful on her?

29. Did GQ ever publish Rory's spec piece about people who love to wait in lines in NYC?

30. Why did Rory tell Jess that she has no car and that her license expired and yet she then drove over to Richard's gravesite just one week later?

EXCLUSIVE: Rachael Ray Spills on Her Surprise 'Gilmore Girls' Role Filling in for Melissa McCarthy!

31. Why was Jack really hovering around Emily? (Get out of here, you filthy honey badger, you don't deserve to breathe the same air as Emily Gilmore.)

32. Why did Emily decide that her time would be best spent working and subsequently terrifying young children at a Nantucket whaling museum?

33. Why did Rory and Christopher have such a tense father/daughter relationship? What happened to them over those missing eight years?

34. Did Rory ever move out of her mother's house?

35. Will Lorelai approve of Rory's final book version of Gilmore Girls? Will Jess be the publisher?

36. And finally, will there be more episodes of Gilmore Girls?

Read Full Story

From Our Partners