Federal judge rules for anti-Trump GOP delegate

Before you go, we thought you'd like these...
Before you go close icon

Anti-Trump forces want to pick VP at convention

A federal judge blocked enforcement Monday of a Virginia law binding delegates to support the primary winner at the nominating convention.

It was a victory for Carroll "Beau" Correll, a delegate to the Republican national convention who argued that the law violated his First Amendment rights to vote for his preferred candidate. Correll supported Ted Cruz in the primary, while Donald Trump received the most votes in the state.

Correll said in an interview that the Trump campaign got "morbidly humiliated" by the outcome of the case.

"They put all their chips on the table and they lost all of them — if I were them I'd go hide in a closet in Trump Tower," he said.

In a follow up statement, Correll made a plea to the like-minded, writing:

"To national political figures that are on the sidelines and awaiting your calling, I implore you to take a step forward from the darkness and into the light. Show us that you have the courage to stand for leader of the Free World, appeal to the better angels of our nature, and to deliver this Republic from the abomination of a Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton presidency."

RELATED: Trump potential Supreme Court justices

Trump potential Supreme Court justices
See Gallery
Trump potential Supreme Court justices

Allison Eid of Colorado

(Photo By Andy Cross/The Denver Post via Getty Images)

Raymond W. Gruender of Missouri

(AP Photo/James A. Finley)

Joan Larsen of Michigan

(AP Photo/David Eggert)

Thomas Lee of Utah

(AP Photo/Francisco Kjolseth , Pool)

Bill Pryor of Alabama

(AP Photo/Dave Martin, File)

David Stras of Minnesota

(AP Photo/Jim Mone)

Diane Sykes of Wisconsin

(Photo by George Bridges/MCT/MCT via Getty Images)

Don Willett of Texas

(AP Photo/Harry Cabluck)

Steven Colloton of Iowa

(Photo via US Government)

Thomas Hardiman of Pennsylvania

(Photo via Roy Engelbrecht/Wikipedia)

Raymond Kethledge of Michigan

(Photo via By SPDuffy527 (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons)

 Senator Mike Lee of Utah

REUTERS/Jim Urquhart

Judge Neil Gorsuch (far Right)

(Photo by David Scull/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Judge Margaret A Ryan 

Image Courtesy of Birmingham Southern College

Edward Mansfield of Iowa

Image Courtesy of The American Law Institute

Keith Blackwell of Georgia

Image Courtesy of Georgia Supreme Court 

 Charles Canady of Florida

(AP Photo/Steve Cannon)

Timothy Tymkovich of Colorado

Image Courtesy of the Supreme Court of Colorado 

Amul Thapar of Kentucky

 (AP Photo/Ed Reinke)

 Federico Moreno of Florida ( far right)

 (AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee, Pool)

 Robert Young of Michigan

(AP Photo/Carlos Osorio)


As a practical matter, the decision appeared to affect at most only some of Virginia's delegates. Some legal experts even said the ruling may apply only to Correll himself, though it was filed as a class action on behalf of all the state's Republican delegates.

Carroll Beau Correll Jr., of Winchester, Va. filed a federal lawsuit against Virginia Attorney General Mark Herring and other state officials.

But it could have a bigger impact on the upcoming Republican National Convention, as it gives some legal cover to delegates wishing to vote their "conscience," rather than for the candidate to whom they're bound.

According to Correll, 20 states have statutes or laws requiring the binding of delegates to candidates, and Trump's detractors had expressed concerns that the candidate — who's known for a history of bringing lawsuits big and small against those he opposes — would use those laws to punish unfaithful delegates.

In Arizona, for instance, delegates are asked to sign a pledge to vote for the winner of the state's primary and those planning to vote their conscience say they've faced threats from the Republican Party chairman there.

Related: Could Delegate's New Lawsuit Derail Trump's Nomination?

One such delegate, Jarrod White, said Arizona GOP Chairman Robert Graham has "publicly come out and threatened delegates that if they don't toe the line and don't vote the way they are told, they will be removed from the delegation, their credentials will be revoked and they'll be removed from the floor."

White says he'll be voting for anyone but Donald Trump, who he says is a "divisive and controversial figure," and predicted 10-12 Arizona delegates in total are planning to vote their conscience and oppose Trump, while 20-30 more are "very sympathetic to the cause and on the fence." The state has 58 delegates.

The Trump campaign, however, is calling the decision a win and a "fatal blow to the anti-Trump agitators," pointing to sections of the judge's ruling that reinforced the traditional interpretation of RNC rules that delegates are in fact bound by state party rules, even if not state laws.

"The court has confirmed what we have said all along: Rule 16 is in effect and thus delegates, including Correll, are bound to vote in accordance with the election results," said Trump Campaign attorney and former FEC Chairman Don McGahn in a statement.

The federal court ruling has no bearing on RNC rules, however, so the disagreement over whether delegates are in fact bound to a candidate will be hashed out next week on the convention floor.

Read Full Story

People are Reading