The sad truth about speed-reading: It doesn't work

Before you go, we thought you'd like these...

Is Speed Reading a Real Thing?

In 2007, shortly after the final volume in the Harry Potter series was released, a woman named Anne Jones read all 784 pages in exactly 47 minutes. To prove that she'd actually read it, Jones -- who has won the World Championship Speed Reading Competition six times -- summarized the major plot points to a group of reporters. They were satisfied with her impromptu book report, which suggests Jones had successfully read the book at 4,200 words per minute.

RELATED: The best tweets from National Grammar Day

25 PHOTOS
Social media reaction to National Grammar Day
See Gallery
The sad truth about speed-reading: It doesn't work
Its grammer day! I hope your enjoying it! Me and my friends are gonna celebrate! #GrammarDay
guys - for those of you correcting my preceding tweet, it has five errors. 😃#ThatsTheJoke #GrammarDay
It's #NationalGrammarDay! What's your biggest grammar pet peeve? https://t.co/xNsmlhgsM0 https://t.co/PVsKnGIhit
Happy #GrammarDay, everyone! https://t.co/1LSYEelk2u
When in doubt, just blame auto-correct. #GrammarDay #GamersGuideToPrettyMuchEverything https://t.co/1WqrA5QvnO
To infinitive and beyond! Happy National #GrammarDay. I love language and learning. Yes, this is part of my shelf. https://t.co/F6q9ceKbCs
Happy #GrammarDay! https://t.co/lXdpC1qkAm
Today is National #Grammar Day! https://t.co/lHcyxtvCfk
Theirs nothing you can do, its #GrammarDay https://t.co/GQyFjHg2hZ
Me Thought Today Be Good Day To Advertise Me Helpy For You English. Happy #NationalGrammarDay https://t.co/pgU2I0KWrT
It's is #NationalGrammarDay. Have a great days. #WeCouldntResists
Today be National Grammar Day, me hopes I get this rite...
Didn't know what picture to use for #NationalGrammarDay, so I had to go with this one https://t.co/HLKKkh2Trm #BYU https://t.co/nwC6svgsZL
Hey wordies, it's National Grammar Day! Don't be peevish--march forth and celebrate!
Grammar nerds: It's your time to shine! #NationalGrammarDay https://t.co/uqvmAAFaRL
Happy Grammar Day! #EnglishHumor #GrammarDay https://t.co/mAa5I25030
It's #GrammarDay! As one of my t-shirts says, "There, their, they're. Choose wisely."
To everyone who uses correct punctuation in text messages: We ❤ you. #GrammarDay https://t.co/oCz9ntnfSB
It's national #GrammarDay! All the more reason to be impeccable during job interviews. Friendly reminder: Supposebly is not a word.
Happy Grammar Day to our US followers! (does that include spelling?) #stationerywithane #GrammarDay https://t.co/UMy5qPFBJp
Happy Grammar Day! Type carefully while enjoying your favourite pack of Lay's! #GrammarDay #LoveToLoveIt https://t.co/j7Votb3D85
ICYMI: #Metaphors and #Similes: #hints and #tips #infographic https://t.co/ni9lgyGxK3 https://t.co/PThSbHLW4B
It's #NationalGrammarDay! Here are 10 tips to improve your grammar via @grammarnet: https://t.co/EGGDTr6nQ2 https://t.co/TExwLtgpT1
Happy National #GrammarDay! https://t.co/ewfMpTXpOl https://t.co/lccOQrmU25
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE
SHOW CAPTION +
HIDE CAPTION

In comparison, even adults who would be considered "good readers" can only read about 200 to 400 words per minute. The promise of speed-reading is a tantalizing one, which is no doubt the reason that the idea has been around since at least the 1950s, when Evelyn Wood came out with her Reading Dynamics training program. As a pair of scientists who study reading wrote this weekend in the New York Times, Wood taught that slow readers are inefficient readers. "The course focused on teaching people to make fewer back-and-forth eye movements across the page," write Jeffrey M. Zacks and Rebecca Treiman, "taking in more information with each glance." And this, essentially, is the basis of many of today's technology-backed solutions for stuffing more words in your eyeballs, including apps that use rapid serial visual presentation -- that is, they speed through words at a quicker rate than our eyes could alone.

Treiman is a co-author on a paper in the May edition of the journal Psychological Science that reviews the evidence for speed-reading, and mostly finds it lacking. "The research shows that there is a trade-off between speed and accuracy," she and her colleagues write. "It is unlikely that readers will be able to double or triple their reading speeds (e.g., from around 250 to 500-750 words per minute) while still being able to understand the text as well as if they read at normal speed."

Put another way, the problem with speed-reading claims is that speed-reading is really just another way of saying "skimming." You can flash as many words as you like in front of your eyes, and though you may be able to understand each word on its own, they won't mean much as a collective whole. Language processing just doesn't work that way. In their Times op-ed, Treiman and Zacks explain the biological reason why:

And yet there are, of course, people who are faster readers than others. Their secret is not so glamorous, and it isn't really something you can apply with the use of the existing speed-reading apps. As Treiman and her co-authors write in their Psychological Science paper, "the factor that most strongly determined reading speed was word-identification ability," which means that an individual's reading speed is more about their language skills than where or how quickly they move their eyes. And by the way: That claim that people who hear an "inner voice" reading the text as their eyes move along are slower readers turns out to be false, according to the evidence unearthed by Treiman and the rest.

In the end, the only reliable way to become a faster reader, then, is to expand your vocabulary -- and the best way to do that is to read more. There is no shortcut, in other words, to getting through the three towering stacks of unread books currently threatening to topple over and cause a literary avalanche on my desk. The only way to read faster is to read a lot.

Read Full Story

People are Reading