MLB recommends netting between dugouts for all 30 ballparks

Before you go, we thought you'd like these...
Before you go close icon
MLB 'Encourages' Teams to Extend Protective Netting


NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) -- Major League Baseball recommended teams have protective netting between the dugouts for any field-level seats within 70 feet of home plate.

The guidelines were announced Wednesday at the winter meetings following a season in which several fans were injured by foul balls, prompting MLB to study fan safety. Most teams are expected to expand their use of netting.

SEE MORE: The 50 'most loyal' athletes of all time

"It is important that fans have the option to sit behind protective netting or in other areas of the ballpark where foul balls and bats are less likely to enter," Commissioner Rob Manfred said in a statement. "This recommendation attempts to balance the need for an adequate number of seating options with our desire to preserve the interactive pre-game and in-game fan experience that often centers around the dugouts, where fans can catch foul balls, see their favorite players up close and, if they are lucky, catch a tossed ball or other souvenir. "

The recommendation also applies to spring training ballparks, many of them owned by municipalities.

"The recommendations strike a balance between providing a reasonable inventory of seats behind protective netting at each stadium while at the same time accommodating fans who desire seats with unobstructed access to players and on field activity," said Dan Halem, MLB's chief legal officer. "Both fan safety and fan choice are extremely important to MLB, and these recommendations reflect those principles."

Look back at the scary incident at Fenway last season that helped spur this decision:

13 PHOTOS
Fenway Park injury
See Gallery
MLB recommends netting between dugouts for all 30 ballparks
BOSTON, MA - JUNE 5: A fan is attended to by medical staff after she was hit by a broken bat during a game between the Boston Red Sox and the Oakland Athletics in the second inning at Fenway Park on June 5, 2015 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)
BOSTON - JUNE 5: Medical personnel remove a fan injured by a broken bat in the second inning. The Boston Red Sox take on the Oakland Athletics in Game 1 of a three game series at Fenway Park. (Photo by Barry Chin/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
BOSTON - JUNE 5: Medical personnel remove a fan injured by a broken bat in the second inning. Larry Lucchino, President and CEO of the Boston Red Sox was also on the scene. The Boston Red Sox take on the Oakland Athletics in Game 1 of a three game series at Fenway Park. (Photo by Barry Chin/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
BOSTON - JUNE 5: Medical personnel remove a fan injured by a broken bat in the second inning. The Boston Red Sox take on the Oakland Athletics in Game 1 of a three game series at Fenway Park. (Photo by Barry Chin/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
BOSTON - JUNE 5: Medical personnel remove a fan injured by a broken bat in the second inning. The Boston Red Sox take on the Oakland Athletics in Game 1 of a three game series at Fenway Park. (Photo by Barry Chin/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
BOSTON, MA - JUNE 5: A fan is attended to by medical staff after she was hit by a broken bat during a game between the Boston Red Sox and the Oakland Athletics in the second inning at Fenway Park on June 5, 2015 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)
BOSTON, MA - JUNE 5: A fan is attended to by medical staff after she was hit by a broken bat during a game between the Boston Red Sox and the Oakland Athletics in the second inning at Fenway Park on June 5, 2015 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)
Boston Red Sox medical personnel tend to a woman, who with was hit by a wooden shard, off a broken bat of Oakland Athletics' Brett Lawrie, in the second inning during a baseball game at Fenway Park in Boston, Friday, June 5, 2015. The game stopped as the woman was taken from the stands on a stretcher down the first base line to a waiting ambulance. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa)
A fan, who was accidentally hit in the head with a broken bat by Oakland Athletics' Brett Lawrie, is helped from the stands during a baseball game against the Boston Red Sox at Fenway Park in Boston, Friday, June 5, 2015. The game was stopped while they wheeled her down the first base line. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa)
A fan is attended to by medical staff after she was hit by a broken bat during a game between the Boston Red Sox and the Oakland Athletics in the second inning at Fenway Park on June 5, 2015 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)
Fans observe a moment of silence before a baseball game between the Boston Red Sox and the Oakland Athletics, at Fenway Park in Boston, Saturday, June 6, 2015, in the area of the stands where a woman was hit and seriously injured by a broken bat during Friday's game. (AP Photo/Michael Dwyer)
BOSTON, MA - JUNE 5: People gather where a woman was seriously injured by a broken base bat during a game between the Boston Red Sox and the Oakland Athletics at Fenway Park on June 5, 2015 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE
SHOW CAPTION +
HIDE CAPTION


Boston, the Los Angeles Dodgers and Philadelphia immediately said they will follow the recommendation. The Phillies hope to install thinner material that is less noticeable.

"We anticipate that such compliance will require us to expand our protective netting behind home plate about 10 feet in width on both sides," Philadelphia Chief Operating Officer Michael Stiles said. ""We understand that our fans differ in their opinions about sitting behind protective netting and we will do our best to accommodate those different preferences,"

Boston is "in the process of evaluating different design options to identify the best solution for Fenway Park and is proactively reaching out to the ticket holders most affected by the planned changes," the Red Sox said.

Cincinnati and Houston said their ballparks already are in compliance.

MLB said it will work with teams and ticket sellers to identify which seats are behind netting. By 2017, the actual tickets are likely to indicate whether they are behind protection.

"We will fight to make these new safety measures more than just recommendations and to make sure the measures are adequate," said Steve Berman, a lawyer for several fans who in July sued MLB in U.S. District Court in San Francisco. "By next season, we don't want any spectators to be under the threat of being harmed by a foul ball or bat injury, period."

Pat O'Conner, president of the National Association of Professional Baseball Leagues, said the minor league governing body will "encourage our clubs to implement these recommendations as soon as practical."

RANKING THE 30 WORST TRADES IN MLB HISTORY:

31 PHOTOS
30 worst trades in MLB history
See Gallery
MLB recommends netting between dugouts for all 30 ballparks

30: Adam Wainwright to the Cardinals

The trade: The Cardinals received Adam Wainwright, Jason Marquis, and Ray King.

Atlanta received J.D. Drew and Eli Marrero.

In 2003, the Braves gave the Cardinals pitching prospect Adam Wainwright who would go on to become a franchise cornerstone. He was the team’s closer during their 2006 World Series win – their first in 24 years – and has become one of the best starters in the MLB with a record of 121-67 and a 2.98 ERA.

In the short-term, this was a good trade for the Braves as J.D. Drew racked up a .305 batting average and 31 home runs, finishing sixth in MVP voting. However, after the Braves lost to the Astros in the NLDS, both Drew and Marrero left the team. Drew would go on to win a World Series, but it was in 2007 with the Red Sox.

Not to overlook the other two pieces of the deal, Jason Marquis spent three seasons in the Cardinals rotation and amassed a 28-21 record with a 3.92 ERA in his first two seasons. Ray King was also a great left-handed relief pitcher for two seasons with the Cardinals as he posted a 2.91 ERA in 163 appearances with the team.

(AP Photo/Paul Beaty)

29: Prince Fielder to the Rangers

The trade: The Rangers received Prince Fielder.

The Tigers received Ian Kinsler and $30 million.

This trade was a simple one-for-one swap of all-star players with $30 million sent to the Tigers as a salary compensation. The fact that the Tigers received $30 million on top of an all-star second baseman in Ian Kinsler goes to show how awful Prince Fielder’s contract and how glad the Tigers are to have him off the books was – to be exact, the Rangers have him signed until 2020 at $214 million.

In his first season with the Tigers, Kinsler was named an all-star and was 4th in the AL in hits (188), doubles (40), and 5th in runs scored (100). He was the 10th toughest batter to strike out, and was awarded the Defensive Player of the Year at second base.

Prince Fielder’s career numbers speak for themselves, but it hasn’t transpired since he moved to Texas. Just a month into his first season with the Rangers, he underwent neck surgery. He had a good regular season in 2015, hitting 23 home runs and collecting a batting average of .305, but in the postseason, his batting average was a very mild .150 with only 3 hits.

(AP Photo/LM Otero)

28: Noah Syndergaard to the Mets

The trade: The Mets received Travis d’Arnaud, John Buck, Noah Syndergaard, and Wuilmer Becerra.

The Blue Jays received R.A. Dickey, Josh Thole, and Mike Nickeas.

At the time, this was a very good trade for Toronto. Dickey had just come off of a Cy Young winning season, and was one of the hottest names on the market. Behind J.P. Arencibia, Josh Thole looked to be a player who could provide depth at the catcher position. Then the 2013 season started, and Dickey finished his first season with the Jays with a 14-13 record and an ERA of 4.21. It’s always risky to give away talented prospects for a more experienced player, and at 39, Dickey was entering the journeyman phase of his career.

While he has excelled in 2015 being taken out of the ace role, Syndergaard (or Thor as fans affectionately call him) has been, dare I say, electric for the Mets. He finished the season with a 9-7 record and a 3.24 ERA, pitching in the World Series in his first ever season in the MLB. d’Arnaud, the other key acquisition for the Mets, has also put up impressive stats for the Mets, with a .245 average and 26 home runs in his major league career. In 2015, d’Arnaud made an appearance in the World Series while Josh Thole spent a good part of the season warming the Blue Jays’ bench.

(Photo by Mike Stobe/Getty Images)

27: Vernon Wells to the Angels

The trade: The Angels received Vernon Wells.

Toronto received Mike Napoli and Juan Rivera.

Having hit 223 home runs over the 11 seasons he spent with the Blue Jays, Vernon Wells was by no means a bad player, but after signing him to a 7-year, $126-million contract back in 2006, the Blue Jays were desperate to unload him to another team. The Angels’ owner Arte Moreno was a more than willing bidder, telling his GM that he would be fired if he didn’t acquire Wells within 24 hours.

Wells’ first season with the Angels went poorly, as he finished the season with a .218 batting average, the lowest batting average out of anyone that season with at least 512 plate appearances. He hit 25 home runs, which amounted to $720,000 per home run for Angels ownership.

Even though the Blue Jays ridded themselves of Vernon Wells’ contract, they didn’t do themselves any favours with the pieces they got in return. After acquiring Mike Napoli, they dealt him to the Rangers four days later in exchange for relief pitcher Frank Francisco. In Juan Rivera’s half-season spent with the Blue Jays, he hit 6 home runs and had a batting average of .243. Nevertheless, it was the Angels who found themselves on the losing end of this deal.

(Rick Madonik/Toronto Star via Getty Images)

26: Aramis Ramirez to the Cubs

The trade: Pittsburgh received Bobby Hill, Mike Bruback and Jose Hernandez.

The Cubs received Aramis Ramirez and Kenny Lofton.

The Pirates received an underwhelming package for Aramis Ramirez who they had drafted back in 1998 and showed lots of promise. Jose Hernandez was released at the end of the 2003 season, Bobby Hill had a good 2004 season and not much else, and Mike Bruback never made it to the majors.

In exchange, Aramis Ramirez spent 9 illustrious seasons with the Chicago Cubs. He had a career .294 batting average with the team to go along with 239 home runs and 806 RBI. In the 2003 postseason, Ramirez was the first Cubs player in history to hit a playoff grand slam off of Dontrelle Willis in Game 4 of the NLCS. Even though Kenny Lofton turned out to be a rental for the Cubs, he did his part for the team, collecting a .327 batting average in 68 games played.

From 2003 to 2011, when Ramirez played for the Cubs, Chicago had 3 postseason appearances to Pittsburgh’s zero. Ramirez went back to Pittsburgh in the twilight of his career, hitting 6 home runs in 57 games and a batting average of .243. He would announce his retirement at the end of the season.

(Photo by Doug Pensinger/Getty Images)

25: Bobby Abreu to the Phillies

The trade: The Phillies received Bobby Abreu.

Tampa Bay received Kevin Stocker.

The former 2-time All-Star, Gold Glover, and Silver Slugger was an expansion draft pick by the Tampa Bay Devil Rays when they first came into the league. It was only hours after he got picked by Tampa Bay that Bobby Abreu got traded to the Phillies for Kevin Stocker.

In just Abreu’s first season with the Phillies, he led the team in batting average (.312) while hitting 17 home runs and 74 RBIs. In addition to his power hitting (he was a home run derby champion), Abreu had great defensive ability, winning the Gold Glove in 2005 – his last season with the Phillies. Abreu played for six different teams, but his time with the Phillies is what will be remembered the most.

Kevin Stocker, on the other hand, was released after two seasons with the Devil Rays. His illustrious career includes 23 home runs and a .254 batting average over seven years. He went from being a Major League Baseball player to a franchise owner of Emerald City Smoothie in Washington. This trade took Tampa Bay ten years to recover from as well as a name change before they could finally make the playoffs.

(AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)

24: Francisco Liriano to the Twins

The trade: The Giants received A.J. Pierzynski and cash.

The Twins received Boof Bonser, Joe Nathan, Francisco Liriano.

Even though they traded for a guy named Boof, this was a deal that the Twins won. I’m talking crossed over then 360 dunked on the Giants. Pierzynski was a great catcher coming off of a great season (a career high .312 batting average). But once he came to San Francisco, his batting average fell to .272 while hitting just 11 home runs. That was the only season he spent with the Giants before getting non-tendered.

And who did the Twins get for this one-season wonder? Joe Nathan, who became as reliable a closer as anyone in the major leagues, converting 44 of 47 save opportunities and earning an ERA of 1.62 in his first season with the Twins. He would continue that over the course of his Twins career, becoming an All-Star in all but three seasons (if you don’t count 2010) and joining the 300 save club.

Francisco Liriano would also prove to be a great pitcher for the Twins. In 2005, he led all pitchers with 204 strikeouts. Then in 2006, he started the season 12-3 with a 2.19 ERA. An injury in August made him fall just short of capturing both the Cy Young and Rookie of the Year that season.

Even though this was an awful trade, it’s not as if it derailed the Giants organization. In fact, it may have benefited them as they probably wouldn’t have been bad enough to draft Buster Posey.

(AP Photo/Ann Heisenfelt,file)

23: Chris Archer to the Rays

The trade: The Rays received Chris Archer, Robinson Chirinos, Sam Fuld, Brandon Guyer and Hak-Ju Lee.

The Cubs received Matt Garza, Fernando Perez, and Zac Rosscup.

Matt Garza was a dominant pitcher for the Rays, most notably in their 2008 World Series run when he was named the ALCS MVP. However, in this eight-player blockbuster deal with the Cubs, the Rays were trading for the future and they got it in the form of now superstar pitcher Chris Archer.

This season was Archer’s best so far, getting his first All-Star Game appearance and recording the second-most strikeouts in the AL with 252. He pitched so well, Rays fans forgot who David Price was.

Garza being included in this package was probably how the Rays were able to land as talented a prospect as Archer. The Rays likely knew that Garza was on the tail-end of his career, because once he got to Chicago, he finished 10-10 with a 3.32 ERA before getting jettisoned to the Rangers two seasons later.

The package they received wasn’t pretty either – Mike Olt, Justin Grimm, C.J. Edwards, and Neil Ramirez all of whom have played a combined total of 220 games in the major leagues.

(AP Photo/Pat Sullivan)

22: Josh Donaldson to the Blue Jays

The trade: Blue Jays receive Josh Donaldson.

Oakland receives Brett Lawrie, Kendall Graveman, Franklin Barreto, Sean Nolin.

If not for Moneyball, Billy Beane would probably be out of a job because of this trade. It’s not as if Donaldson became an overnight sensation in Toronto. He was already a highly regarded player, but his 2015 season with Toronto was a breakout year for the AL MVP winner when he, Bautista, and Encarnacion formed the most feared trio in all of baseball.

Donaldson also became the first player to win the MVP right after being traded since 1984 when Willie Hernandez got traded to the Phillies. Donaldson set career highs in home runs (44), RBIs (131), and runs scored (142). He was so good that even Angels fans chanted MVP when he stepped up to bat.

Brett Lawrie’s season, meanwhile, was characterized by at-bats such as this. Lawrie’s time with the Jays was defined by his short temper and extensive injury history, both of which carried over to the Athletics.

The Jays did give up three prospects in Graveman, Barreto, and Sean Nolin which can come back to haunt a team. The Athletics’ only hope of winning this deal is if they can develop these three prospects into budding stars, but as long as Donaldson is still in the prime of his career, the Jays came away big winners in this trade.

(Photo by Rob Carr/Getty Images)

21: Jose Bautista to the Blue Jays

The trade: Toronto receives Jose Bautista

The Pirates receive Robinson Diaz

Josh Donaldson wasn’t the only player who became a star after being traded to Toronto. Prior to arriving in Toronto, Bautista never found a home playing for four different teams. He spent five seasons in Pittsburgh where he never hit more than 16 home runs. Nobody in the Pirates organization could’ve ever imagined Bautista would become the player that he is today.

Robinson Diaz spent two seasons with the Pirates after being traded – the only two seasons he would spend in the major leagues. He hit .295 with 18 RBIs in 31 career games with Pittsburgh before he got optioned back to Triple-A in 2009.

Listing Bautista’s accomplishments would be pure sadism, but I’m going to do it anyway. He’s been named to six consecutive All-Star Games from 2010 to 2015, a 2-time home run leader (in 2010 and 2011 when he hit 54 and 43 home runs respectively) and a 3-time Silver Slugger winner. In his first postseason appearance in 2015, Bautista led his team with 4 home runs, including one in Game 5 against the Rangers that will spawn many oral histories and a 30-for-30 documentary sometime in the future.

(Rick Madonik/Toronto Star via Getty Images)

20: Max Scherzer to the Tigers

The trade: Arizona received Ian Kennedy and Edwin Jackson from the Tigers

Detroit received Max Scherzer and Daniel Schlereth from the Diamondbacks, and Austin Jackson and Phil Coke from the Yankees

New York Yankees received Curtis Granderson from the Tigers

It was only a matter of time before a three-team trade ended up on here. The Yankees were winners, the Tigers were winners and losers at the same time, and the Diamondbacks were big losers. On the one hand, the Tigers were able to flip Ian Kennedy and Edwin Jackson for a Cy Young winner in Max Scherzer. But they also gave up Curtis Granderson and in turn received Austin Jackson and Phil Coke.

However, Granderson was being actively shopped by the Tigers in order to reduce their payroll. Granderson had some great seasons with the Yankees – including 2011 when he was the first player to have 40 home runs, 10 triples, and 25 stolen bases. However, Max Scherzer’s phenomenal contributions to the Tigers (a Cy Young award, the two-time leader in wins in the AL) was more than enough to make up for Granderson’s loss.

Ian Kennedy isn’t a bad pitcher by any means. He won 21 games in 2011 and placed fourth on the Cy Young ballot, but his numbers dipped considerably afterwards before he got shipped out to the Padres. Even though Kennedy served the team well, it’s highly unlikely that Diamondbacks fans are over the fact that they gave up Max Scherzer.

(Photo by Mark Cunningham/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

19: Jake Arrieta to the Cubs

The trade: Chicago Cubs received Jake Arrieta and Pedro Strop

Baltimore received Scott Feldman, Steve Clevenger, and cash

Watching the NL Cy Young presentation must’ve stung for the Baltimore Orioles organization. Lacking a true ace but having a wealth of power hitters, imagine how good the Orioles would be if they had held on to Jake Arrieta. Instead, after witnessing Arrieta’s historic second half of the season for the Cubs, they are left wondering what could’ve been.

Arrieta was with the Orioles for four years. In 2012, he started the season 3-9 with a 6.13 ERA before being sent back down. The Orioles thought they were getting rid of dead weight when they gave him to the Cubs, but instead they gave them a future Cy Young winner.

Scott Feldman spent just one season in Baltimore, pitching to a 5-6 record with a 4.27 ERA before he got shipped off to the Astros. Steve Clevenger, meanwhile, has 2 home runs in 3 seasons with the Orioles. Do I need to bring up Arrieta’s numbers now? Okay, fine.

Arrieta’s second-half of the 2015 season was literally historic. After the All-Star break, he posted an ERA of 0.75 – the lowest mark in MLB history. He gave up a total of nine runs in 15 starts, amassing a 12-1 record. Outside of a complete-game shutout against the Pirates, Arrieta’s post-season numbers left much to be desired. However, that shouldn’t take away from his award-winning season, plus he’s in the prime of his career so he’ll adjust that sooner rather than later.

(Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)

18: Joe Jackson to the Indians

The trade: Cleveland received Joe Jackson

Philadelphia received Bris Lord

Shoeless Joe Jackson may be most infamous for his involvement in the 1919 Black Sox scandal, but before that, he spent five seasons with the Cleveland Naps (later known as the Cleveland Indians). This was after the Philadelphia Athletics gave up on him and decided to trade him for Bris Lord.

Bris Lord, which sounds like a minister for circumcision, had 13 home runs and a batting average of .256 over his 8-year career. Shoeless Joe bested that batting average in his rookie season. In his first season with Cleveland, Jackson hit .408, a rookie record that still stands. The following season, he batted .395 and led the AL in triples, hits, and total bases. He only had 54 home runs to his name, but that’s not what he was known for.

Jackson became a World Series champion* with the Black Sox, but he provided the Naps with five quality seasons that helped shape his legacy as the baseball legend that he is today. Meanwhile, Connie Mack – the owner of the Philadelphia Athletics – is still convinced to this day that Bris Lord was integral to his team’s success.

(Photo Reproduction by Transcendental Graphics/Getty Images)

17: Lorenzo Cain to the Royals

The trade: Kansas City received Lorenzo Cain, Alcides Escobar, Jeremy Jeffress, and Jake Odorizzi

Milwaukee received Zack Greinke and Yuniesky Betancourt

This proves that it is possible to create a championship core off of a trade. Alcides Escobar enjoyed a breakout year in 2015 and was instrumental in Kansas City’s World Series being named the ALCS MVP. Ultimately, I put Lorenzo Cain’s name in the title because he came in third in AL MVP voting. Odorizzi was included in the package, but he spent most of his time in Kansas City’s AAA affiliate before being shipped out to Tampa Bay for James Shields and Wade Davis.

The Royals won their World Series because of an overall team effort, but these two players stood out, especially in their aggressive base-running. Cain scored the winning run from first on an RBI single in Game 6 against the Blue Jays, and Escobar opened the World Series with an inside-the-park home run.

Sure the Brewers got Zack Greinke – ironically enough, it’s because he didn’t want to play for a rebuilding team – who played well in Milwaukee. However, the rest of the team wasn’t so he was dealt to the Angels for Jean Segura, Ariel Pena, and Johnny Hellweg. Greinke’s selfishness led to him playing for three different teams, and likely a fourth in 2016, while the Royals continue to reap the rewards.

(Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)

16: Alex Rodriguez to the Yankees

The trade: New York Yankees received Alex Rodriguez

Texas received Alfonso Soriano

A-Rod had just come off of an MVP season in Texas, but the Rangers were looking to move his expensive contract. They figured now was the time to strike while the iron was hot, so they swapped Rodriguez for Alfonso Soriano. In addition, the Rangers had to pay $67 million of Rodriguez’s contract when they dealt him. A-Rod, previously a shortstop, also found a home at third base, which allowed the Yankees to keep Derek Jeter.

Rodriguez wasted no time paying dividends for the Yankees, hitting 36 home runs and 106 RBIs. He would win two more AL MVPs with the Yankees in 2005 and 2007 as well as three more Silver Sluggers, a Hank Aaron Award, and a World Series. And he did all of that while playing by the rules*. His 33 home runs in 2015 proves that he’s still got it.

Alfonso Soriano is a talented player in his own right, but his numbers and awards simply don’t compare to A-Rod’s while he only spent two seasons with the Rangers before being shipped out to the Nationals for Brad Wilkerson, Terrmel Sledge, and Armando Gallarraga.

(Photo by Theo Wargo/WireImage)

15: Frank Robinson to the Orioles

The trade: Baltimore received Frank Robinson

Cincinnati received Milt Pappas, Jack Baldschun, and Dick Simpson

Frank Robinson established himself as an all-time legend with the Cincinnati Reds when he hit 38 home runs in his rookie season. Although the Reds would come close to winning the World Series, losing in 1961 to the Yankees, Robinson never did win a title with Cincinnati. It was only after he got dealt to the Orioles that Robinson became a 2-time World Series champion.

It was a shocking decision for the Reds to ship Robinson over to Baltimore since he was still 30 years old at the time, and still had a lot left in him. Even though Milt Pappas was a good pitcher, the backlash over the deal made it difficult for him to ever get settled in with the Reds, and he was traded after just three seasons. After the trade, Baldschun only recorded one save in his entire career.

Not only did Robinson win two World Series with the Orioles, he led the league in home runs (49), RBIs (122), and batting average (.316) becoming a Triple Crown winner in just his first season in Baltimore. Robinson has been inducted into the Hall of Fame, and his number is retired by both the Reds and the Orioles, but the botched deal – as well as him infamously calling Frank Robinson “an old 30” – forever tarnished Bill DeWitt’s legacy.

(Photo by Focus On Sport/Getty Images)

14: Pedro Martinez to the Red Sox

The trade: Boston received Pedro Martinez

Montreal received Carl Pavano and Tony Armas Jr.

Spoiler alert: this isn’t the only time Pedro Martinez appears on this list. Not long after he became a prized acquisition by the Expos, Pedro Martinez was dealt to the Red Sox in 1997. Martinez was signed to a monster 6-year, $75 million contract which he paid off right away.

In his first season with the Red Sox, he won the Cy Young, and in his second season, he won the pitchers’ Triple Crown by leading the league in ERA (2.07), strikeouts (313), and a 23-4 record. However, among all of his accomplishments, what Red Sox fans will remember most is Martinez leading the team to their first World Series in 86 years, effectively ending the Curse of the Bambino.

What did Montreal receive in return? A rookie in Carl Pavano who pitched to a total record of 24-35 and a 4.83 ERA with the Expos. Tony Armas’ time in Montreal was overshadowed due to various injury concerns, and he filed for free agency in 2006. All told, the Expos never recovered from this deal, as it made the team so bad they had to relocate to Washington.

(Photo credit should read JOHN MOTTERN/AFP/Getty Images)

13: Paul Konerko to the White Sox

The trade: Chicago White Sox received Paul Konerko

Cincinnati received Mike Cameron

Paul Konerko has become synonymous with the White Sox, and they have the Reds to thank for that. Konerko has achieved it all with Chicago. In 2000, they made the playoffs for the first time since 1993 but it was during their 2005 championship run where Konerko came alive.

Over 5 games in the ALCS, Konerko recorded 7 RBIs and was named the ALCS MVP. He then hit a grand slam in Game 2 of the World Series and caught the final out to complete the sweep over the Astros. He would spend the rest of his career in Chicago.

Mike Cameron spent one season in Cincinnati, but for good reason… he was included in a package for Ken Griffey Jr. Cameron’s most iconic moment, hitting four home runs in one game, would come as a member of the Seattle Mariners. Ken Griffey would provide some memorable moments for Cincinnati, but most of his awards came while he was with the Mariners.

Ultimately, what makes the White Sox the winners of this trade is that Konerko will always have something that Ken Griffey never had: a World Series title.

(Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

12: Keith Hernandez to the Mets

The trade: New York Mets received Keith Hernandez

St. Louis received Neil Allen and Rick Ownbey

Keith Hernandez was a star for the Cardinals, as he was instrumental for them in their 1982 World Series victory. However, he and Cardinals management had a falling out and he demanded to be traded. Even though Cardinals manager Whitey Herzog never regretted this deal, everyone else associated with the Cardinals organization was.

Hernandez moved from a World Series winning team to one that had just finished 68-94, but in just his second season, Hernandez turned the Mets’ fortunes around. In 1984, the Mets finished 90-72, 6 and a half games above the Cardinals, while Hernandez came in second in the NL MVP. In addition to being a World Series champion in 1986, Keith Hernandez also dated Elaine Benes and was accused of spitting on a fan.

The players St. Louis got in return did nothing to alleviate fans’ displeasure with the trade. In 1985, Neil Allen had a 1-4 record and a 5.59 ERA. He would later get sold to the Yankees. Rick Ownbey spent most of his time in the minor leagues, and in total started 7 games in a St. Louis uniform.

(Photo by Andrew D. Bernstein/Getty Images)

11: Mark McGwire to the Cardinals

The trade: St. Louis received Mark McGwire

Oakland received T.J. Mathews, Eric Ludwick, and Blake Stein

There was probably not a better home-run hitter on the planet than Mark McGwire who hit 52 home runs in 1996 and 34 in 1997 with the Athletics before he was traded to St. Louis. At the time of the trade, many didn’t expect McGwire to stay in St. Louis since his contract was up at the end of the year. But once he re-signed with the Cardinals, the Athletics owners realized how big of a mistake they made.

McGwire, Sosa, and Ken Griffey Jr. were all looking to break Roger Maris’ single-season home run record of 61. McGwire was the first to break it as he finished the season with 70 home runs, while all who participated respected the integrity of the game*.

Eric Ludwick’s career statistics include a glowing record of 2-10 and an 8.35 ERA. While T.J. Mathews had a respectable career with Oakland, he was no Mark McGwire, while Blake Stein was traded two seasons after he arrived.

Mark McGwire was one of the most exciting baseball players to watch, and while many question the legitimacy of his numbers, do we want to focus on that, or do we want to see him sock a few dingers?

Dingers! Dingers! Dingers!

(AP Photo/Mary Butkus)

10: Willie Hernandez to the Tigers

The trade: Detroit received Willie Hernandez and Dave Bergman

Philadelphia received Glenn Wilson and John Wockenfuss

Before the Phillies could learn how to pronounce John Wockenfuss’ last name, Willie Hernandez won the Cy Young and was voted the MVP immediately after getting traded to the Tigers. He was one of four relief pitchers to ever win the MVP as he helped the Tigers to a 104-58 season and a World Series title. It was only after Hernandez became a member of the Tigers that he achieved individual accolades, becoming a 3-time All-Star as well.

Glenn Wilson had a successful career with the Phillies, most notably in 1985 when he hit 102 RBIs, but he never had the same impact on his team as Willie Hernandez did. Meanwhile, Wockenfuss was released from the Phillies after two seasons. Dave Bergman also found success with the Tigers as he notched a career high 44 RBIs in his first season.

As it was noted before, it wasn’t until Josh Donaldson this season that a team traded for a player who subsequently won the MVP. Of course, the Hernandez deal is more noteworthy since he delivered his team a World Series later on that year.

(AP Photo)

9: Roberto Alomar to the Blue Jays

The trade: Toronto received Roberto Alomar and Joe Carter

San Diego received Fred McGriff and Tony Fernandez

This trade was a slam dunk for the Blue Jays. Dare I say, it was a… home run? Nobody? Having acquired Alomar and Joe Carter in 1990, these were the two most vital pieces to Toronto’s back-to-back World Series titles in 1992 and 1993.

Of course, everyone remembers Joe Carter’s series-winning home run, but Alomar was arguably more important to the Blue Jays’ success. He helped the Jays to their first World Series appearance in 1992 with a crucial – and massively underappreciated – game-tying home run in Game 4 of the ALCS. In every season with Toronto, Roberto Alomar won a Gold Glove. Carter was an important player in his own right, as he led the team in home runs and RBIs in 1994 and 1995.

Tony Fernandez was an important contributor for the Jays, and was one of the standout players during Toronto’s pennant-winning 1985 season. However, once he got traded to San Diego, however he only spent two seasons before he went to the Mets in 1993. McGriff played well once he got to San Diego, but he was dealt in 1993 when it was clear that the Padres were out of playoff contention.

(AP Photo/George Nikitin)

8: Lou Brock to the Cardinals

The trade: St. Louis received Lou Brock, Paul Toth, and Jack Spring

Chicago Cubs received Ernie Broglio, Bobby Shantz, and Doug Clemens

After an 18-win season with the Cardinals, Ernie Broglio was a solid starting pitcher and was thought to be a good pickup for the Cubs. Once he joined the club, however, it was a different story where he had a 7-19 record with a 5.40 ERA before he retired at age 30. Bobby Shantz was 38 years old at the time he was acquired and Doug Clemens was traded away after a year.

Once he joined the Cardinals, Lou Brock’s batting average went from .260 to .348. He was best known for his base-stealing ability as he finished his career with 938 stolen bases. He became a two-time World Series Champion with the Cardinals and a 6-time All-Star. When he joined the Cardinals, they were 28-31 which was good for 8th in the National League. Brock helped his team storm back as they took the pennant that year and later the World Series.

Whereas the Cubs gave up on him, St. Louis never looked back as Lou Brock spent his final 16 seasons with the Cardinals. He’s also part of the 3,000 hit club and a member of the Hall of Fame.

(AP Photo/Jeff Roberson)

7: Miguel Cabrera to the Tigers

The trade: Detroit received Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis

Florida received Dallas Trahern, Cameron Maybin, Andrew Miller, Burke Badenhop, Mike Rabelo, and Frankie De La Cruz

At the time, this didn’t look like such a great trade for the Tigers. It seemed like they were giving up too much for Cabrera and the D-Train who was approaching the tail end of his career. And while Willis’ time in Detroit was plagued by injury, Miguel Cabrera became nothing short of a superstar.

He signed an eight-year, $152 million contract in 2008 which would only be surpassed by his eight-year, $248 million extension in 2014 – a deal so massive that the Tigers had to dip into taxpayers’ money to get it done. His most iconic moments are in 2012 and 2013, when he won his first two MVP awards and achieved a Triple Crown in 2012 – leading the league in batting average (.330), home runs (44), and RBIs (139).

Of the six players that the Tigers sent the Marlins, the only two that panned out were Andrew Miller and Cameron Maybin. With Florida, Miller only appeared in 29 games, went 6-10, and had an ERA of 5.87. He would get dealt to the Red Sox in 2010. Cameron Maybin never spent a full season with the Marlins and he got dealt to the Padres after three seasons.

(Photo by Mark Cunningham/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

6: John Smoltz to the Braves

The trade: Atlanta received John Smoltz

Detroit received Doyle Alexander

As far as one-for-one deals go, it’s hard to find one that’s more lopsided than this. Doyle Alexander spent 18 seasons in the MLB, and his last three in Detroit came courtesy of this deal. He got off on the right foot in Detroit, getting to a 9-0 start and a 1.53 ERA, doing his best to make Tigers fans forget that they traded away a future Hall of Famer. Once they got to the postseason, the wheels came off when he struggled mightily in the ALCS.

Over the course of his career, Doyle Alexander’s postseason totals are an unflattering 0-5 with an 8.38 ERA. He became an All-Star in 1988, but a fractured jaw in 1989 forced him to retire.

Atlanta didn’t know what they were about to get when they traded for minor leaguer John Smoltz. In fact, his numbers were less than flattering as he went 4-11 with a 5.73 ERA in double-A and triple-A. Once he arrived in the majors, everything changed. He would spend 20 of 21 seasons with the Braves, collecting 154 saves and a 3.26 ERA. He won a World Series title in 1995 and was the NL Cy Young winner in 1996.

(AP Photo/Reinhold Matay)

5: Curt Schilling to the Astros

The trade: Houston received Curt Schilling, Steve Finley, and Pete Harnish

Baltimore received Glenn Davis

The Orioles shipped out three prospects in search of a first base upgrade over Randy Mulligan. What they got instead was Glenn Davis – no, not “Big Baby” Davis, although their skill set is pretty comparable. Davis had 164 home runs in six seasons prior with the Astros, but a neck injury limited his first season with the Orioles to just 49 games. After three seasons with the Orioles, he retired.

The prospects that Houston received would all become All-Stars later on in their career, although the centerpiece of this deal is obviously Curt Schilling. Schilling currently ranks 15th all-time with 3,116 career strikeouts while he went 11-2 with a 2.23 ERA in the postseason. Even though he only spent one season with the Astros, Orioles fans are left wondering what could’ve been after they parted ways.

Even though Steve Finley’s offensive numbers don’t pop out, he was a steady force for the Astros, while he recorded 13 outfield assists in his first season. Pete Harnish spent just four seasons in Houston, but in that time he compiled a 45-33 record and had an ERA of 3.41.

(Photo by Rick Stewart/Getty Images)

4: Ryne Sandberg to the Cubs

The trade: Chicago Cubs received Ryne Sandberg and Larry Bowa

Philadelphia received Ivan DeJesus

Larry Bowa spent four seasons with the Cubs and brought a veteran presence to the clubhouse. He was meant to fill in for Ivan DeJesus, and he posted a respectable .247 batting average.

Ryne Sandberg, considered a throw-in during the trade, made an immediate impact for the Cubs. He won the NL MVP in 1984 and was a Gold Glove winner for 9 consecutive seasons. He spent 15 seasons in Chicago and had a career .284 batting average to go along with 282 home runs and 2,836 hits. He was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2005.

As noted before, Sandberg was a throw-in, as this trade was meant to be a swap of shortstops Larry Bowa and Ivan DeJesus. Even though DeJesus had a disastrous season with the Cubs prior to the deal (he hit .194), the Phillies still viewed him as an upgrade over the aging Larry Bowa. He was, but not much of one. He only stuck around for three seasons with the Phillies, while his batting average was a less than stellar .249. The Phillies won the pennant in 1983, but that’s all DeJesus had going for him.

(Photo by Tim DeFrisco/Getty Images)

3: Pedro Martinez to the Expos

The trade: Montreal received Pedro Martinez

Los Angeles Dodgers received Delino DeShields

Delino DeShields Jr. currently plays for the Texas Rangers, but he is likely reminded constantly of the lopsided deal his father was a part of. DeShields filled a need at second base for the Dodgers after Jody Reed left. Once he came to the Dodgers, his batting average slipped from .277 to .241 and he only spent three seasons in LA before he left for free agency.

Despite the fact that Pedro Martinez went 10-5 with a 2.61 ERA for the Dodgers, the team never believed he could become a starter. But once he was dealt to the Expos, he moved into the starting rotation and amassed an 11-5 record with a 3.42 ERA. Martinez would later win the NL Cy Young in 1997 and he finished his career with the Expos with a 17-8 record and a 1.90 ERA. Sure he accomplished more once they sent him to Boston, but it was with the Expos that Pedro Martinez became a superstar.

Wait a second. The Expos made a good trade? Something must be wrong. They must’ve made an equally bad trade to permanently destabilize their franchise.

(Steve Dunn/Allsport)

2: Cliff Lee to the Indians

The trade: Cleveland acquired Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore, Brandon Phillips, and Lee Stevens

Montreal acquired Bartolo Colon and Tim Drew

And there it is. You know that Bartolo Colon has been in the league for a long time when he was even playing for the Montreal Expos. Lee Stevens and Brandon Phillips were already proven talents, but Grady Sizemore and Cliff Lee were highly regarded prospects. As it turned out, three out of four players would pan out for the Indians, with Cliff Lee becoming one of the best pitchers during his playing time.

Bartolo Colon has played for almost every MLB team in existence – or close to it – and after being acquired at the deadline by the Expos, he and Jorge Nunez were shipped off at the start of 2003 to the Chicago White Sox for Orlando Hernandez, Rocky Biddle, and Jeff Liefer. Tim Drew is famous for being “J.D.’s brother. No, the other one”.

Before he became a perennial All-Star with the Reds, Brandon Phillips developed in the Indians system while Grady Sizemore became a franchise cornerstone for the Indians. He joined the 30-30 club in 2008, had 3 All-Star appearances, and won two Gold Gloves. Cliff Lee also became something of a legend in Cleveland, spending 8 seasons with the team and winning the Cy Young in 2008 after a 22-3 record.

(Photo by Andy Lyons/Getty Images)

1: Babe Ruth to the Yankees

The trade: New York Yankees received Babe Ruth

Boston received $100,000

Because there really was no other choice for number 1. This deal was so bad, so illogical, that there is a curse named after it. After the Red Sox inexplicably sold the best player in baseball to their archrivals for $100,000 in return, they fell under the Curse of the Bambino and couldn’t win another World Series for 86 years. Before the deal, the Red Sox had won five World Series titles, while the Yankees didn’t become perennial winners until after they acquired Babe Ruth. Pretty funny how that works out.

The Red Sox had won five out of fifteen World Series, and Babe Ruth won three of them. Once he moved to the Yankees, he won four World Series titles – the first four in franchise history. 95 years later, the Red Sox still have yet to win four more World Series titles. He was the AL MVP in 1923 and led the AL in home runs 10 times while with the Yankees.

So why did the Red Sox sell the greatest to ever play baseball for $100,000? Nobody knows for sure, although the most popular theory is that the money was used to finance the Broadway production of No, No, Nanette. However, the show’s first performance didn’t come until five years after the Ruth sale and I’m sure it flopped just as badly as the Red Sox after the deal.

Anyway, it’s been fun torturing fanbases revisiting these lopsided trades just as we get set for another crazy offseason. But the MLB has been around for over a century, and as such there have been plenty of bad trades to go around. Narrowing it down to 30 was a difficult task and some had to be left out. But of course, that’s what the comments section is for – if you disagree with a ranking, or you thought a deal should’ve made the list but didn’t, feel free to leave it in the comments below.​

(Photo by Iconic Archive/Getty Images)

of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE
SHOW CAPTION +
HIDE CAPTION

Read Full Story

From Our Partners