Judge off Jordan case, denies calling him 'hog'

Before you go, we thought you'd like these...
Before you go close icon

Michael Jordan
See Gallery
Judge off Jordan case, denies calling him 'hog'
Basketball pro Michael Jordan. (Photo by Steve Kagan//Time Life Pictures/Getty Images)
Michael Jordan (Photo by Steve Grayson/WireImage)
Michael Jordan (Photo by Steve Granitz/WireImage)
Michael Jordan (Photo by Steve Grayson/WireImage)
UNITED STATES - MARCH 19: Michael Jordan (Photo by The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images)
26 Oct 1994: Michael Jordan of the Scottsdale Scorpions looks on during an Arizona Fall League game.
1988-1989: Guard Michael Jordan of the Chicago Bulls (center) goes up for two. Mandatory Credit: Mike Powell /Allsport
Chicago Bulls All-Star forward # 23 Michael Jordan file photos. (Photo by Tom Berg/WireImage)
Michael Jordan during 2005 Michael Jordan Classic Basketball Game - April 16, 2005 in New York City, New York, United States. ***Exclusive*** (Photo by Johnny Nunez/WireImage)
9 Feb 1997: Guard Michael Jordan of the Chicago Bulls looks on during the NBA All-Star game. Mandatory Credit: Brian Bahr /Allsport
Charlotte Bobcats team owner Michael Jordan smiles as the students cheer during his introduction at Vance High School on Thursday, March 21, 2013. Bobcats Sports and Entertainment, along with FOX Sports Carolinas/Sports South announced a $200,000 donation to Y Achievers, a YMCA of Greater Charlotte program that operates in partnership with Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools. (Jeff Siner/Charlotte Observer/MCT via Getty Images)
Michael Jordan (Photo by Shareif Ziyadat/FilmMagic)
Former professional US basketball player Michael Jordan delivers a press conference at the Palais de Tokyo in Paris on June 12, 2015 to present Palais 23, an event at the Palais de Tokyo from June 12 to 14 to celebrate the 30th anniversary of Jordan Brand. AFP PHOTO / PATRICK KOVARIK (Photo credit should read PATRICK KOVARIK/AFP/Getty Images)

Associated Press

CHICAGO (AP) -- A federal judge in Chicago withdrew from a civil case involving Michael Jordan after lawyers for the former Chicago Bulls star lawyers accused the jurist of comparing Jordan to a "hog" and "Dr. Frankenstein," though the judge denies the descriptions were aimed directly at the former NBA player.

The legal fracas arose in a 4-year-old civil case in which Jordan star sued Dominick's Finer Foods LLC after the grocery store chain invoked his name and persona without permission in a 2009 Sports Illustrated advertisement.

Jordan's lawyers this week succeeded in getting Judge Milton I. Shadur to remove himself from the case after they alleged he described the six-time NBA champion as "greedy," comparing him to a "hog" and to "Dr. Frankenstein."

In the ad, Dominick's congratulated Jordan on his induction into the Basketball Hall of Fame and offered a $2-off steak coupon. The court already found Dominick's liable, and the lingering dispute is over damages. Jordan, 50, is seeking $2.5 million.

Shadur, a recent Jordan filing argued, also showed bias in slapping down the star's assertion that his actual damages may run to $10 million. At one hearing, Shadur said in an allusion to the stock market, "The bulls may make money and the bears may make money, but the hogs get slaughtered."

In reluctantly removing himself, the 89-year-old judge issued a defiant, scathing attack on Jordan's legal team for "launching a groundless and unwarranted personal attack on this Court's integrity."

"That out-of-bounds ($10 million) claim is what has occasioned this Court's characterization ... in terms of greed, a characterization that is not altered by the response that billionaire Jordan plans to turn over any recovery to his not-for-profit foundation," he wrote.

At earlier hearings, Shadur also denied calling Jordan a "hog" or "Dr. Frankenstein." He employed those descriptions, he insisted, in reference to Jordan's damages claims - not to Jordan himself.

Technically, Shadur denied the defense motion that he recuse himself. But given the hub-hub created by Jordan's lawyers in arguing judicial bias, Shadur wrote in his ruling that he was exercising his prerogative as a senior judge to withdraw.

He was worried, he explained, that his consternation over the lawyers' accusations presents "a danger that subliminal forces could perhaps unwittingly affect the decisional process in this case."

Read Full Story

People are Reading