Search AOL Mail
AOL Mail
AOL Favorites

Vatican: 848 priests defrocked for abuse since '04

May 6, 7:10 PM EDT

GENEVA (AP) -- The Vatican revealed Tuesday that over the past decade, it has defrocked 848 priests who raped or molested children and sanctioned another 2,572 with lesser penalties, providing the first ever breakdown of how it handled the more than 3,400 cases of abuse reported to the Holy See since 2004.

The Vatican's U.N. ambassador in Geneva, Archbishop Silvano Tomasi, released the figures during a second day of grilling by a U.N. committee monitoring implementation of the U.N. treaty against torture.

Tomasi insisted that the Holy See was only obliged to abide by the torture treaty inside the tiny Vatican City State, which has a population of only a few hundred people.

But significantly, he didn't dispute the committee's contention that sexual violence against children can be considered torture. Legal experts have said that classifying sexual abuse as torture could expose the Catholic Church to a new wave of lawsuits since torture cases in much of the world don't carry statutes of limitations.

Tomasi also provided statistics about how the Holy See has adjudicated sex abuse cases for the past decade. The Vatican in 2001 required bishops and religious superiors to forward all credible cases of abuse to Rome for review after determining that they were shuffling pedophile priests from diocese to diocese rather than subjecting them to church trials. Only in 2010 did the Vatican explicitly tell bishops and superiors to also report credible cases to police where local reporting laws require them to.

The Vatican statistics are notable in that they show how the peaks in numbers over the years - both of cases reported and sanctions meted out - roughly parallels the years in which abuse scandals were in the news. And they showed that far from diminishing in recent years, the number of cases reported annually to the Vatican has remained a fairly constant 400 or so since 2010, the last year the scandal erupted in public around the globe. These cases, however, concern mostly abuse that occurred decades ago.

The Associated Press reported in January that then-Pope Benedict XVI had defrocked 384 priests in the final two years of his pontificate, citing documentation that Tomasi's delegation had prepared for another U.N. hearing monitoring a treaty on the rights of children. That documentation matched data contained in the Vatican's statistical yearbooks.

Tomasi told the AP on Tuesday that the January figures were "incomplete" and that the data he provided to the U.N. committee Tuesday was the first ever comprehensive year-by-year breakdown of cases reported and adjudicated. The figures, however, only cover cases handled directly by the Holy See, not those handled by local diocesan tribunals, meaning the total number of sanctioned priests is likely far higher.

The data showed that since 2004, the Vatican had received some 3,400 cases, had defrocked 848 priests and sanctioned another 2,572 to lesser penalties.

There are over 410,000 Catholic priests around the world, according to the Catholic News Service.

The latest spike began in 2010, when 464 cases were reported, more than twice the amount in 2009. Starting in that same year, the Vatican began resorting more and more to the lesser penalty of sentencing accused priests to a lifetime of penance and prayer rather than defrocking them. The Vatican often metes out such sentences for elderly or infirm priests, since defrocking them would essentially render them destitute in their final years.

Prior to 2010, these lesser sanctions were only handed out to about 100 or so priests each year.

Tomassi stressed the lesser sanctions still amounted to punishment and the abuser was "put in a place where he doesn't have any contact with the children."

The main U.S. victim's group, SNAP, praised the Vatican for releasing the data, saying "Every step toward more transparency about clergy sex crimes and coverups is good." But it called the numbers "meaningless" and urged the Vatican to release the names and whereabouts of molesters.

Nick Cafardi, a U.S. canon lawyer and former chairman of the U.S. bishops' lay review board that monitored clerical abuse, said the statistics clearly showed a positive evolution in how the church dealt with the abuse problem.

"Given where the church came from - with the pendulum swung squarely to the side of the accused priest whose explanations were almost always believed - this is a move away from that and more toward giving credibility to victims, which is progress," he said. "Maybe not perfect progress, but progress."

Tomasi's appearance marked the second time this year that the Vatican has been hauled before a U.N. committee to face uncomfortable questions about how it has handled the crisis of priests who raped and molested tens of thousands of children, and the bishops who covered up for them. The Vatican was required to appear as a signatory to U.N. treaties.

The vice-chair of the committee, Felice Gaer, pressed Tomasi to acknowledge whether the Holy See considered sexual abuse to be a form of torture. She cited decisions from many international bodies, including the U.N. tribunals for Yugoslavia and Rwanda, which have held that sexual violence is indeed a form of torture.

"I'm not a lawyer," Tomasi said. But he didn't dispute the contention, saying merely that the alleged torture and the behavior of the person inflicting it must be "consistent with the definition of the convention."

The U.N. convention defines torture as "any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person" to obtain information, to punish or coerce and is inflicted with the "consent or acquiescence" of a public official.

Gaer said afterward that she considered Tomasi's response to be a clear admission by the Holy See that sexual violence can be a form of torture.

Victims' advocates and legal groups have said the Catholic Church could be exposed to a new round of litigation if courts agree that abuse can constitute torture. Other legal experts, however, have expressed doubts that U.S. courts would be swayed by an attempt to reclassify rape as torture merely to get around the statute of limitations. The statute issue has proved to be a major stumbling block for many victims, since many are unable to cope with the trauma of the abuse until it's too late to pursue civil damages.

"The Vatican has long minimized these offenses and the resulting harm," said Pam Spees, a senior attorney at the Center for Constitutional Rights, which provided documentation to the U.N. committee detailing the scope of the clerical abuse problem. "But the committee's recognition (of abuse as a form of torture) could help open additional channels for victims to seek justice and reparations, including, potentially, relief from restrictive statutes of limitations and civil remedies, all of which contributes to preventing more harm."

Tomasi acknowledged that there were problems in the past, including when priests were transferred from diocese to diocese after psychiatrists gave them a clean bill of health, thinking that a pedophile could be cured with therapy.

"The culture at the time would allow this to happen," he said. "Unfortunately, that was a mistake as experience has shown."

He told the committee that "there is no climate of impunity but there is a total commitment to clean the house" and prevent more abuse.

"I think we have crossed a threshold ... in our evolution of the approach to these problems," he concluded. "It's clear that the issue of sexual abuse of children, which is a worldwide plague and scourge, has been addressed in the last 10 years by the church in a systematic, comprehensive, constructive way."

Join the discussion

1000|Char. 1000  Char.
Hi Jeanette! May 07 2014 at 12:16 PM

Holy See - my a...

Flag Reply +1 rate up
boardsrbetter May 07 2014 at 1:12 PM

we know... christianity is a cult of child molesters who have forgotten the defintion of religion is belief.

Flag Reply +1 rate up
2 replies
Pastor Fletcher boardsrbetter May 07 2014 at 2:10 PM

This is not true boardsbetter. You evidently do not know the word of God. You are talking about people, not the body of Christ. Christians follow Christ. Church goers go to a building called church, but have never been converted.

Flag Reply +1 rate up
3 replies
erin boardsrbetter May 07 2014 at 3:31 PM

"We" don't know anything of the sort. Catholocism and Christianity are not even close to being the same thing. Christianity is not a religion - it is a faith. Anyone can be a Christian regardless of their religious affiliations. But, identifying as Catholic, or going to a church does not make you a Christian. So, your statement is skewed. I would go so far as to say that organized religions may be a cult for child molesters who have forgotten the definition of religion. But, the definition of "religion" is not faith. Religions are groups that formed, and made up their own rules, and then argued over who was right.

Flag Reply 0 rate up
T. Wayne Harris May 07 2014 at 1:16 PM

Well now I may start respecting the Catholics again. It is about time.

Flag Reply +2 rate up
greatbirdusa May 07 2014 at 1:18 PM

This too was caused by Global warming..!

Flag Reply +2 rate up
paulatkinson22 May 07 2014 at 1:22 PM

The Catholic church is broke. It has always been broken. For every good deed they've ever done, an equal number bad deeds have been done. If you want to believe in God, by all means, do so. You don't need a church to believe in God. You don't have to confess your sins to a priest, or pray to some obscure saint to intercede, or rub on beads in the name of Mary. You don't have to give them money to build magnificent buildings and live lavishly all over the world. Like recently the Archbishop of Atlanta was forced to sell his $2.2 MILLION dollar home. $2.2 MILLION!!!! Think how much good the Catholic church could do if it spent the billions is uses to build fancy houses, churches and ornate palaces and instead used it to actually help mankind.

Flag Reply +3 rate up
1 reply
erin paulatkinson22 May 07 2014 at 3:26 PM

Which is exactly why Martin Luther posted a list of things wrong with the Catholic church, and started the Protestant movement. Notice how "Protestant" has the word "protest" within?

Flag Reply 0 rate up
paulatkinson22 May 07 2014 at 1:27 PM

3,400 hundred cases since 2004. I wonder what the historical wreckage of the Catholic church has been? 100,000? 1,000,000? 10,000,000? More??? This behavior didn't just start in the last 50 years. It's been going on for CENTURIES!

Flag Reply +2 rate up
1 reply
The Mayor paulatkinson22 May 07 2014 at 2:34 PM

At least it is being addressed. Now let's release the numbers on teachers and leaders of other denominations and muslim torturers and rapists. As someone else commented "it's front page news if the sicko is Catholic".

Flag Reply +1 rate up
1 reply
David S. The Mayor May 07 2014 at 4:07 PM

Yeah, how many priests who molested kids are in jail in this country? Next to none! As to the "muslim torturers and rapists" those are overwhelmingly in other countries.

Flag +1 rate up
oahunan May 07 2014 at 1:36 PM


Flag Reply +1 rate up
1 reply
mweisslasvegas oahunan May 07 2014 at 2:18 PM

i hate to say this but if theres a "plan" then why did it happen in the first place? I dont knock any religion
everyone has a right to chose whom and what they worship to and it should be respected. I just don't understand this "plan". It makes no sense to have plan that would include letting violent and horrible things happen to people. If the plan is to let people learn for themselves first, well obviously that doesnt and has never worked since the beginning. There needs to be a new plan.

Flag Reply 0 rate up
positiveteam May 07 2014 at 1:39 PM

new book: "horny priests" will sell billions

Flag Reply +1 rate up
babpeace May 07 2014 at 1:56 PM

they should be in jail . Pedophiles should be in a specific jail for pedophiles only
and never let out.

Flag Reply +1 rate up
1 reply
jabaileydc babpeace May 07 2014 at 2:16 PM

Better yet, tattoo pedophile on their foreheads and release them into the general population.

Flag Reply 0 rate up
oujoou May 07 2014 at 1:57 PM

Major. Major. Housecleaning going on there. :) This new pope is far out . . . although I probably won't see him when I visit Rome and the Vatican for the first time in the fall. :(

Flag Reply +1 rate up
aol~~ 1209600


More From Our Partners