Homeowners Association Could Be Sued in Trayvon Martin Case

Before you go, we thought you'd like these...
Before you go close icon
SANFORD, Fla. -- If Trayvon Martin's family sues over his death, they might not target George Zimmerman but instead the homeowners association of the neighborhood where the shooting happened and Zimmerman lived.

That's because if Zimmerman's claim that he shot the unarmed 17-year-old in self-defense is upheld by prosecutors, a judge or a jury, Florida's so-called "stand your ground" law would protect him from a lawsuit. But his clearance or acquittal wouldn't stop Martin's parents from suing The Retreat at Twin Lakes Homeowners Association -- and its insurance policies and assets would make it a much more lucrative target than Zimmerman, even if he is eventually convicted of a crime.

Plus, lawyers say, Exhibit A would be a newsletter sent by the association to residents in February, the same month as the shooting. It said Zimmerman was the go-to person for residents who had been the victims of a crime.

Under the heading "Neighborhood Watch," the newsletter's message recommended that residents first call police and then "please contact our Captain, George Zimmerman ... so he can be aware and help address the issue with other residents."

That seeming endorsement of Zimmerman exposes the 7-year-old association to possible legal action by Martin's parents, homeowners association attorneys said.

"It's almost like if you give your son the keys to a brand new Corvette when he turns 16" and he gets in an accident, said Roberto Blanch, a South Florida attorney who specializes in homeowners associations. "You may be seen as enabling the occurrence or the loss."

Atty.: Civil Lawsuit Likely in Martin Shooting



















Zimmerman has admitted to fatally shooting Martin during a confrontation Feb. 26 but has said it was in self-defense. Zimmerman spotted Martin from his truck as the teen was returning to the house of his father's fiancee from a convenience store. It was dusk on a rainy evening.

"This guy looks like he is up to no good," Zimmerman told a police dispatcher before the confrontation.

When Zimmerman got out of his truck and started following him, the dispatcher told him, "OK. We don't need you to do that."

Moments later, residents of The Retreat at Twin Lakes heard screaming and at least one gunshot. Police officers arriving at the gated community found Martin shot dead in the chest.

By designating Zimmerman the neighborhood watch captain in its newsletter, the homeowners association "is stuck" if it's sued, said Justin Clark, an attorney based in Longwood, Fla., whose practice includes real estate law.

"So, if you're going to send out a newsletter saying, 'Hey, he is the captain. Whatever he says goes,' You have now basically rented a free police officer for your neighborhood," Clark said. "He certainly took on that role with the homeowners association, and it seems to me that they recognized that."

One of the Martin family's attorneys, Daryl Parks, indicated last month that a civil lawsuit against the homeowners' association was likely.

"They mention George Zimmerman by name as the captain for the neighborhood watch, and they tell you if you see something suspicious, call the Sanford Police Department and call George Zimmerman," Parks told board members of the National Association of Black Journalists last month. "So the close nature of the working relationship is as clear as it can be."

Don O'Brien, an officer with The Retreat at Twin Lakes Homeowners Association, said, "No," and closed the door on a reporter who contacted him at his home. No one answered the door at the homes of two other association officers, Jenna Lauer and Cynthia Wibker. All live inside the complex of more than 250 townhomes.

A woman who answered the telephone at the association's management company, Leland Management, said no one would comment. She declined to give her name.

Zimmerman told Sanford police detectives that he had lost track of Martin and was returning to his vehicle when Martin attacked him from behind.

Then-Police Chief Bill Lee said detectives were unable to arrest Zimmerman because of Florida's self-defense law, which gives wide leeway to use deadly force and eliminates a person's duty to retreat in the face of danger.

The decision not to arrest Zimmerman has provoked an international outcry, prompting Lee to step down temporarily and the state attorney who normally handles cases out of Sanford to recuse himself. Gov. Rick Scott appointed a special prosecutor to investigate and decide whether to file charges.

Zimmerman had developed a reputation for monitoring the neighborhood. He was well known to local police dispatchers, having made 46 calls to them since 2004, according to department records. Some of those records list the caller familiarly as just "George." The neighborhood had experienced a recent rash of burglaries, and some neighbors welcomed Zimmerman's efforts.

A PowerPoint presentation put out by the Sanford Police Department for neighborhood watch groups, however, makes it clear that Zimmerman's role had limits. The presentation warns volunteers not to try to be police themselves but to "work with the police."

If Zimmerman were to be convicted of a crime, the door would likely be wide open to a lawsuit -- Florida courts have held that homeowners associations can be held liable in wrongful-death cases.

A state appellate court in South Florida ruled seven years ago that a Miami homeowners association was partially at fault in the death of a visitor whose estranged husband entered the gated community and killed her.

Who would pay in the event of such a lawsuit would probably be determined by the type of insurance coverage the association has, Clark said. Some policies may be wide enough to cover Zimmerman's actions. If there is no policy or the policy in place is very narrow in its coverage, homeowners likely would have to pay out of their own pockets through higher monthly assessment fees because most associations don't have very deep reserves, he said. He noted that policies typically cover about $1 million.

"I almost guarantee you there are going to be checks written," Clark said.

Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. The information contained in the AP news report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or otherwise distributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press. Active hyperlinks have been inserted by AOL.

See also:
Mezuzah Lawsuit Ends as Condo Association Caves

Las Vegas Homeowners Association Scandal Claims 4th Victim
Most Controversial HOA Moves of the Year


18 PHOTOS
Houses Priced Like Average Cars
See Gallery
Homeowners Association Could Be Sued in Trayvon Martin Case

Price: $29,900

This Two Rivers home for sale is a bank-owned property, but don’t let that deter you. Priced just under $30,000 and with three bedrooms, fresh paint, new carpets and refinished hardwood flooring, this home is a steal. But if you prefer to drop $30K on a set of wheels, a base model of the 2012 Honda CRV may be up your alley.

See the listing for more details on this home

Price: $39,900

This Kentucky home listing states the house is move-in ready, with newer hardwood floors, updated vinyl and windows. Although it’s priced below Louisville’s median home value of $86,000, the home is on the smaller side with only two bedrooms, one bath and 788 square feet of living space. For the same price, a buyer could go green with a 2012 Chevy Volt.

See the listing for more details on this home.

Price: $30,000

This two-bedroom, two-bathroom Arkansas home is a great investment opportunity since it used to be a duplex and, according to the listing, could easily be converted back. The home is situated on a larger block with a fenced yard and covered parking for two vehicles. This North Little Rock home’s automotive counterpoint? A 2012 Dodge Dakota truck, which runs about $28,000 to $32,000.

See the listing for more details on this home

Price: $24,000

Less than $25,000 is quite a deal for a home built in the past 15 years. This three-bedroom, two-bath Tennesee home was built in 1999 and features 1,200 square feet of living space as well as a two-car garage. For $25,000 in car value, how about a 2012 Toyota Camry?

See the listing for more details on this home

Price: $54,900

Priced at almost $55,000, this Wichita home is on the pricey end of our list. The adorable cottage offers two bedrooms, one bathroom and plenty of updates -- including hardwood floors, a new kitchen, windows and roof. For the same price, a 2012 Mercedes-Benz E-Class could be a classy choice.

See the listing for more details on this home

Price: $39,900

Located two hours southwest of Minneapolis, Sleepy Eye is a smaller lake town. This slice of real estate is move-in ready with newer paint, flooring and furnace. The home also has a covered porch and detached two-car garage. For the same price, you could fill the garage with a Buick Enclave, which costs the same as the home: $39,000.

See the listing for more details on this home

Price: $42,000

A two-bedroom, two-bath rambler could be the perfect place for a Florida getaway. The New Port Richey home for sale is located north of Tampa and St. Petersburg and has 1,068 square feet of living space with a formal dining room, bright kitchen with breakfast bar and outdoor patio. The potential car equivalent of the house is a Acura MDX, also priced at $42,000.

See the listing for more details on this home

of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE
SHOW CAPTION +
HIDE CAPTION

More on AOL Real Estate:
Find out how to
calculate mortgage payments.
Find
homes for sale in your area.
Find
foreclosures in your area.
See celebrity real estate.
Read Full Story

Find a New Home

Buy
Rent
Value
Powered by Zillow

From Our Partners