Bank Sold Your Loan? Mortgage Settlement May Deal You Out

Before you go, we thought you'd like these...
Before you go close icon


Under the terms of the historic $25 billion settlement announced last week, the country's largest mortgage servicers must pay $17 billion to distressed borrowers in the form of loan modifications, mostly through principal write-downs.

Painted as long-awaited redress for bank misdeeds, the penalty is supposed to funnel relief to the segment of homeowners hit hardest by the housing bust: "underwater" borrowers at risk of default.

But while the agreement appears poised to offer loan modifications to at least some distressed homeowners, details of the deal that have been released so far suggest that the assistance is not only extremely limited in scope but also, in the words of one expert, seemingly "arbitrary."

That's because, regardless of the standing of a loan, qualification for principal reduction appears to hinge on one question: "Who owns your mortgage?"

If the answer is "not a major bank," then there is a high probability that the borrower won't see a dime in assistance. That may strike some as unfair, says Jack Guttentag, an emeritus professor of finance at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School, because borrowers "don't have any say about who ends up owning their loan."

Loans owned by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, which account for half of the nation's mortgages, are already completely off-limits for write-downs under the deal, while FHA-insured loans, which also comprise a considerable portion of total market share, are also ineligible.

In addition, investor-owned loans which, like those owned by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, are packaged into securities, also generally fall outside of the deal's purview, according to the attorneys general. The North Carolina Department of Justice estimates that only 20 percent of modifications performed under the deal will touch private investor-owned loans.

Brace for Disappointment?

So what's left? Only relatively obscure loans that sit on banks' books, according Guy D. Cecala, CEO of Inside Mortgage Finance Publications Inc. "Most banks [don't] hold 30-year fixed-rate mortgages on their books," Cecala says, noting that mortgages owned by the five servicers account for just 7.3 percent of all U.S. mortgages.

The pool shrinks even further when you consider that most borrowers need to be at least underwater if not delinquent to qualify for principal reduction. Cecala estimates that just one in 10 bank-owned loans fits that mold. That would appear to leave less than one percent of American loans eligible for most of the modifications (excluding the relatively small amount of private investor-owned loans that stand to receive some relief from the deal).

Given those broad exclusions, many homeowners, who at first might think that they qualify for the deal, seem set up for disappointment.

Obama Hails Housing Settlement



















That's certainly the case for Christy Mannering, who took out a 30-year, fixed-rate, zero-down mortgage for $189,000 from Countrywide (now owned by Bank of America) just prior to the housing bust. Mannering, who is a web designer at the University of Delaware and also runs the blog scrink.com, had always been under the impression that her servicer owned the loan. "Their name is all over everything," she says.

So when she and her husband heard of the settlement reached between attorneys general, Bank of America and other major servicers last week, the couple breathed a sigh of relief. With a home that's underwater by tens of thousands of dollars (according to Zillow, their house is worth $139,000, Mannering says), they believed that they were likely candidates for assistance under the terms of the deal.

But after a little research, Mannering discovered that they do not qualify because Bank of America sold their loan to what she calls a "phantom loan owner:" Fannie Mae. Unfortunately for the family, Fannie Mae-owned loans, are not eligible for modifications under the deal.

"I would have never thought that it is not [held by] Bank of America," Mannering said. "Bah, humbug."

According to publisher Cecala, the mortgages that are most likely eligible for the relief are "legacy loans" from the go-go days of the housing boom: payment-option adjustable rate mortgages.

The loans offer artificially low "teaser rates" that exclude principal payment at first, but later "recast," often resulting in financial distress. The loans, which banks often keep on their books because they are too difficult to securitize, "became underwater very, very quickly," Cecala said, and the ones still limping along are likely to draw the attention of banks looking for ways to pay their share of the $17 billion penalty. But banks have already modified many of these loans, Cecala said, in order to keep them from defaulting. So only a fraction of them are still eligible for modifications.

A Possible Break for Jumbo and Second-Lien Loans

In addition, bank-owned jumbo loans, which are so big that they exceed the limit of what government-sponsored entities are usually allowed to underwrite, are likely candidates for the modifications. But they are generally healthy loans, since borrowers have always needed to meet relatively high standards to acquire them. That means only a small minority of these mortgages will qualify for write-downs as well.

Second liens, which banks tend to hold on their books, are another group of mortgages that could serve as fodder for banks looking to meet their modification quotas. But this option, mortgage experts say, is particularly unpalatable to lenders.

"There is incentive to do a larger principal reduction on the first lien, as it improves the position of the second lien," reads recent Amherst Securities Group L.P. report, which argues that banks are incentivized by the deal to modify private investor-owned mortgages in order to improve the standing of their second liens. (If a borrower receives a first-mortgage modification, then he is more likely to pay his second mortgage.)

The report also highlights the general incentive that banks have to use private investor-owned loans to pay their penalty credits: modifying a private investor-owned loan costs the bank almost zilch -- investors take the hit instead.

Contradicting the Amherst Security Group report's predictions, state attorneys general have said banks will not pass along most of their penalties from the deal to private investors. After all, they say, under the terms of the settlement, banks get fewer cents on the dollar for paying their penalty through private investor-owned loans, and may only modify those loans if their contracts with investors permit modifications. Cecala agrees, estimating that, out of all loans modified under the settlement, only 10 percent of them will be private investor-owned.

But Laurie Goodman, who co-authored the Amherst Securities Group report, told AOL Real Estate that she doesn't "see how they can make their numbers with only portfolio loans [bank-owned loans]." And Cecala acknowledged that, given the relatively small number of bank-owned loans that may qualify for modifications, banks would seem to have quite a challenge ahead of them if they want to reach $17 billion in modifications by primarily using bank-owned loans.

If banks do pay much of their penalty by modifying private investor-owned loans, that would extend the deal's coverage beyond a favored group of bank-owned loans to a wider swath of distressed mortgages.

Also see:
Foreclosed Homeowners Get More Time to Request a Review

Foreclosure Fire Sale: Will Bulk 'REO to Rental' Program Fly?
Billboard House Advertises a Way Out of the Housing Crisis


12 PHOTOS
10 Cities Getting Slammed by Foreclosures
See Gallery
Bank Sold Your Loan? Mortgage Settlement May Deal You Out

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +32%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 2,273
Unemployment: 7.6%
% home value down from peak: -12.42%

Columbus hit its median home value peak in the first quarter of 2006. Since that time, home values have declined a relatively modest 12.4%, including a 3.4% drop last year. By the second quarter of 2012, Fiserv projects that homes in the area will lose another 2.3% of their value. Median family income in Columbus is above the national average, and unemployment is just 8%, a full percentage point less than the national average. Despite the fact that things don’t look so bad for the Columbus housing market compared to other regions, the city foreclosure rate still increased by 32% last quarter. A total of 2,273 homes were foreclosed upon during that time.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Columbus, Ohio

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +35%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 1,743
Unemployment: 11.2%
% home value down from peak: -59.3%

There is arguably no single housing market with a worse long-term outlook than southwest Florida, and the Cape Coral-Fort Myers region is the worst of these. Housing prices in the have already dropped 59.3% from their peak, and Fiserv project them to decline another 12.2% by the second quarter of next year. According to Corelogic, 47% of the homes in the Cape Coral-Fort Myers area are worth less than their mortgages because of declining values. Foreclosures have increased 35% in the last quarter, and with no sign of recovery in the immediate future that trend may worsen in the coming months.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Fort Myers, Fla.

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +36%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 1,348
Unemployment: 11%
% home value down from peak: -59.1%

As of last month, Vallejo-Fairfield had the second-highest foreclosure rate in the country, with one out of every 51 homes being foreclosed upon in the third quarter of this year. This was a 36% increase in foreclosures from the second quarter. Home values have dropped 7.5% in the past year and are projected by Fiserv to drop an additional 4.9% by the second quarter of 2012. A remarkable 53% of homes in the region are worth less than their mortgages. This is the seventh highest rate of homes with underwater mortgages in the country.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Fairfield, Calif.

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +41%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 2,174
Unemployment: 14.9%
% home value down from peak: -54%

Fresno’s economy has continued to suffer since housing prices began to drop in 2006. It currently has an unemployment rate of 14.9%, which is one of the highest in the country. Home prices peaked in the first quarter of 2006 and have been decreasing since. The metropolitan area also has one of the highest underwater mortgage rates in the country, with a negative equity share of nearly 46%. In the last year alone home prices have dropped 11%.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Fresno, Calif.

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +44%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 1,039
Unemployment: 11.6%
% home value down from peak: -53.4%

More than 1,000 homes were foreclosed upon in the Palm Bay-Melbourne-Titusville region last quarter, a 44% increase from the previous three-month period. Nearly half of the region’s homes are worth less than their mortgages. With Fiserv projecting home values would drop 7.1% by next year and another 4.9% the year after that, things may just get even worse.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Titusville, Fla.

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +49%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 2,559
Unemployment: 9.5%
% home value down from peak: -39.3%

Jacksonville has experienced a quarterly increase in foreclosures of nearly 50%. Home prices have dropped 39.1% since their peak in the second quarter of 2006. The metropolitan area’s negative equity share also exceeds 46%, making it among the worst in the country for underwater mortgages. Home prices are expected to decrease another 10.7% by the second quarter of 2012.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Jacksonville, Fla.

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +55%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 1,956
Unemployment: 8.7%
% home value down from peak: -15.9%

Nearly 2,000 homes were foreclosed upon during the last quarter, a 55% increase from the previous three months. Unlike many of the regions on this list with accelerating home foreclures, Cincinnati’s local economy is doing fairly well. Home prices are only down 15.9% from their peak in the first quarter of 2006. Unemployment and median family income are both better than average. One possible explanation for this recent increase may be that nearly a third of the total decline in home value since the peak has occurred in the past 12 months.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Cincinnati, Ohio

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +57%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 1,673
Unemployment: 11%
% home value down from peak: -51.4%

The Sarasota-Bradenton-Venice metropolitan area has seen the third largest increase in the country in foreclosures in the third quarter. However, only 1,673 homes out of the 311,475 on the market were foreclosed upon. The housing market has suffered a great deal since housing prices peaked in the first quarter of 2006. Since then, overall home prices have dropped 51.4%.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Venice, Fla.

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +67%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 2,003
Unemployment: 6.6%
% home value down from peak: -15.8%

The Boston metropolitan area is considered to have a particularly resilient housing market. In the most recent quarter, however, foreclosures have increased 67%. Home prices have only dropped 15.8% since they peaked in the third quarter of 2005. The national average is -32.3%. From the second quarter of 2010 to the second quarter of 2011, home prices dropped a mere 1.7%.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Boston, Mass

Quarterly increase in foreclosures: +151%
# of Foreclosures Q3 2011: 1,358
Unemployment: 6.9%
% home value down from peak: -14.9%

Albuquerque’s housing market, like Boston’s, is relatively healthy. While home prices decreased 32.3% nationally after their peak, home prices in Albuquerque only decreased 14.9% since they peaked. Regardless, foreclosures have recently skyrocketed. In the third quarter of 2011, the number of foreclosures in Albuquerque increased 151%. According to New Mexico Business Weekly, the lack of job creation in the area has been a major contributor to this problem.

See foreclosed homes for sale in Albuquerque, N.M.

of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE
SHOW CAPTION +
HIDE CAPTION
Read Full Story

Find a New Home

Buy
Rent
Value
Powered by Zillow

From Our Partners