HOPE Scholarship Shortfall: Dashing Dreams in Georgia?
Until now, the Georgia Hope Scholarship promised students full tuition at Georgia public colleges, provided that the student graduates with and maintains a "B" (3.0) average. This program has kept talented students in the state and greatly increased the number of students there who go on to college. But its funds are drying up.
Part of the program's trouble is its success. The number of students qualifying for HOPE has increased exponentially, with most college-bound high school students now graduating with a "B" average or higher. With such a large number qualifying, the money is going fast.
The fact that HOPE is based on GPA alone may have led the crisis. Allegations of grade inflation at high schools have prompted tougher standards for HOPE recipients, because two-thirds could not maintain the "B" average in college. Now, students must have a 3.0 GPA in math, language arts, science, social studies and a foreign language--leaving out "easy A" classes that can boost a GPA.
Another major factor in the funding crunch is that colleges have steadily raised their tuition and fees over the years, with HOPE picking up the tab. Since so many Georgia college students didn't have to pay, there wasn't much protest.
Some of the proposed changes to the HOPE program include:
- Dropping the grant to 80 or 90 percent of tuition costs
- Raising the required grade point average (from 3.0 to 3.2)
- Awarding a flat-rate grant (such as $10,000 a year), regardless of the cost of the college
- Disallowing payment for remedial college classes
- Only giving hope to the needy, as was its original purpose
Changes to HOPE that may make more sense:
- Giving the Scholarship to the top 100,000 to 150,000 students in the state
- Requiring a freshmen to score in the 85th percentile on the SAT or ACT to get the scholarship, or reward it retroactively to students that receive a B average in their freshman year. (These rules are applied to home-schoolers.)
- Incorporating a minimum SAT/ACT score to qualify, as suggested by State Rep. Fran Millar, R-Dunwoody, to eliminate grade inflation tied to HOPE
- Changing HOPE to a loan that's forgiven if a student maintains a 3.0 GPA or higher, as recommended by students at Georgia State